Spoilers are unmarked per wiki policy on Moments pages.
- Natalie really hates "Baby It's Cold Outside".Eric: It's a great song, and a classic!Natalie: Yeah! It's been putting the "hip" in Rohypnol since 1944!Eric: What are you talking about? It's a cute and flirty Christmas song.Natalie: Maybe if you're Bill Cosby...
- The abuse of Baby Jesus.Josh: Not Baby Jesus!
- His What the Hell, Hero? in response to Natalie's accusations.
Natalie: What kind of psychopath creates a fake profile (whacks him with Baby Jesus) and then starts a fake relationship (whacks him with Baby Jesus) online?Josh: Well what kind psycho flies across the country and just shows up on somebody's front lawn?Natalie: You said—and I quote!—"I wish you were here with me for Christmas."Josh: That's just something people say, like "Your baby's so cute!" or "My diet starts tomorrow!" Everybody knows that! Well, apparently not everybody...Natalie: (Death Glare) - The bar patrons' (especially Tag and the bartender's) reactions to Natalie's Butter Face.Tag: Hey, be respectful! She has a condition!
- Natalie's California-millennial slang doesn't quite carry over to small-town Lake Placid.Josh: Savage? Gnarly? Aggro?Natalie: You're the one who told me to look up the lingo!Josh: Yeah, real words like "rappel" and "harness"! You sound like you have millenial Tourette's!
- This Freudian Slip:Natalie: Yeah! I'll climb anything that mo...ves...Josh & Tag: (Stunned Silence)
- This Freudian Slip:
- Josh and Natalie have a tender moment when she gets too scared to descend the climbing wall...then he shoves her off to get her down.
- Owen's Attention Whore tendencies is Played for Laughs at it's finest during the Lin family's Christmas caroling.Natalie: (Walking behind them with Josh) Owen seems psychotically into this.Josh: (holding a stereo, exasperated) You have no ideaOwen: (yells) Proud voices! Loud voices! Come on!
- When one of the elderly women at the retirement home requests them to sing "Baby, it's Cold Outside", the very song Natalie hates:
Bob: I think we can make that happen. Who wants to take the duet?Natalie: Big mystery there, Bob.- After Josh volunteers for him and Natalie to sing it, much to the latter's chagrin, in the background, you can see Owen throwing a tantrum like a child, then kicking the snow, and slipping on the ground, with Chelsea screaming.
- Josh's really bad dating app pictures.Natalie: Dude, you're holding an axe. You literally look like an axe murderer.Josh: I was going for the rugged look. (Natalie swipes) Who doesn't like a bathroom selfie? And I looked kind of cut that day!Natalie: No one loves a bathroom selfie! Also, why are you holding a wrench?(Natalie swipes and laughs at the picture of Josh holding rope)Natalie: Okay, okay, come here. You're holding a wrench, an axe, and some rope. Were you actually trying to find a girlfriend or the person who murdered Colonel Mustard in the library?
- After giving her a justified What the Hell, Hero? speech after the whole situation unravels, Tag ends with:Tag: And by the way—Die Hard is not a Christmas movie!Natalie: (Looks incredibly offended)
- Grandma June's line during The Stinger sells it:June: Hey you two. Quick question. What's a dick pic?Josh: (to Natalie) I think you should take this one...