Follow TV Tropes

Following

History VisualNovel / PhoenixWrightAceAttorneyTrialsAndTribulations

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: This is the first game in the series where you play as more than one character, but the game only has one objection theme, which plays regardless of who the player character currently is. Later main series entries would have separate objection themes for each playable character.

Added: 512

Changed: 721

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheDon: Bruto Cadaverini never appears personally, but he's often referenced as a terrifying mob boss who scares even the ''police'', and nobody in the underworld dares cross him. [[spoiler: So when he forces Furio to pay his granddaughter Viola's hefty medical bills (Which Furio was responsible for, as he caused the accident that injured her), Furio is left scrambling for the money and eventually resorts to murder.]]
* DoomedByCanon: "Turnabout Beginnings" has Mia going up against Miles Edgeworth on his first case as prosecutor, and it's been established previously that Edgeworth had a perfect record before the events of the first game. This doesn't leave much room for defendant Terry Fawles to get out scot free. [[spoiler:Terry ends up committing suicide via poison while on the witness stand, leaving the case with no conclusion and thus not affecting Edgeworth's record.]]
* DownerEnding: [[FlashBack Case 4]]: [[spoiler:Mia Fey was [[AcquittedTooLate THAT]] close to proving Terry Fawles' innocence for both the current murder and the events five years earlier but instead of continuing his testimony he [[DrivenToSuicide commits]] [[SuicidePact suicide]] in front of the entire courtroom, traumatizing both Mia and Edgeworth.]]

to:

* TheDon: Bruto Cadaverini never appears personally, but he's often referenced as a terrifying mob boss who scares even the ''police'', and nobody in the underworld dares cross him. [[spoiler: So when he forces Furio to pay his granddaughter Viola's hefty medical bills (Which Furio was responsible for, as he caused the accident that injured her), bills, Furio is left scrambling for the money and eventually resorts to murder.]]
* DoomedByCanon: "Turnabout Beginnings" has Mia going up against Miles Edgeworth on his first case as prosecutor, and it's been established previously that Edgeworth had a perfect record before the events of the first game. This doesn't leave much room for defendant Terry Fawles to get out scot free.be vindicated. [[spoiler:Terry ends up committing suicide via poison while on the witness stand, leaving the case with no conclusion and thus not affecting Edgeworth's record.]]
* DownerEnding: [[FlashBack Case 4]]: [[spoiler:Mia Fey was [[AcquittedTooLate THAT]] ''[[AcquittedTooLate that]]'' close to proving Terry Fawles' innocence for in both the current murder and the events five years earlier but instead of continuing his testimony he [[DrivenToSuicide commits]] [[SuicidePact suicide]] in front of the entire courtroom, traumatizing both Mia and Edgeworth.]]



* DubInducedPlotHole: In Case 2, when Godot first comes up, Atmey states that Edgeworth personally named him the best prosecutor in the country, yet, in Case 5, not only have the two not met, but Edgeworth states he's never even heard of him. This is the result of a translation error - the Japanese line is supposed to be a metaphorical remark stating Godot was now the "strongest" prosecutor with Edgeworth having left the country. However, this could still be interpreted as Atmey trying to intimidate Phoenix.

to:

** In response to Dahlia's gushing about Phoenix, Mia scoffs that to the rest of the world, he's "a dime a dozen". This is several years before Phoenix saves her sister's life, and probably the only time in the series that Mia is wrong about anything.
* DubInducedPlotHole: In Case 2, when Godot first comes up, Atmey states that Edgeworth personally named him the best prosecutor in the country, yet, in Case 5, not only have the two not met, but Edgeworth states he's never even heard of him. This is the result of a translation error - the Japanese line is supposed to be a metaphorical remark stating Godot was now the "strongest" prosecutor with Edgeworth having left the country. However, this could still be interpreted as Atmey trying lying to intimidate Phoenix.

Added: 367

Changed: 362

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The Big Bad trope here was more properly Big Bad Duumvirate. The other Big Bad is Godot. The two factions fight, making a Big Bad Ensemble.


* BigBad: [[spoiler:Morgan and Dahlia]] serve as the BigBad of this game and arguably of the original Phoenix arc.

to:

* BigBad: [[spoiler:Morgan and Dahlia]] serve BigBadDuumvirate: [[spoiler:Dahlia serves as the BigBad main Big Bad of this game and arguably is teamed up with Morgan Fey, a GreaterScopeVillain. Dahlia is also another GreaterScopeVillain since her evil against Diego Armando prompted his FaceHeelTurn into Godot, another BigBad who seeks misguided vengeance against Phoenix, and Godot's actions that are unrelated to the [[BigScrewedUpFamily Fey clan]] are proof that she is a GreaterScopeVillain.]]
* BigBadEnsemble: [[spoiler:Dahlia Hawthorne and Godot are two [[BigBad Big Bads]] that fight each other. Dahlia's murderous ways that drive several
of the original cases and caused the other BigBad into evil make her both a BigBad and a GreaterScopeVillain. Godot's attempts to get misguided revenge by prosecuting only cases which Phoenix arc.defends makes him another BigBad.]]

Added: 537

Removed: 553

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* TheCon: The fourth case is about how a cop's sister is kidnapped by her boyfriend, asking for a ransom of an expensive diamond of their father's at a mountain river. It was all staged in order to sell the diamond and split the millions of dollars amongst themselves. However, all of THAT was a scam; the sister planned this all along and jumped into a river with the diamond, keeping it for herself. (Until it was lost in the river, leaving her with nothing but a criminal background and a lot of karma to hit her over the head later.)



* MassiveMultiplayerScam: The fourth case is about how a cop's sister is kidnapped by her boyfriend, asking for a ransom of an expensive diamond of their father's at a mountain river. It was all staged in order to sell the diamond and split the millions of dollars amongst themselves. However, all of THAT was a scam; the sister planned this all along and jumped into a river with the diamond, keeping it for herself. (Until it was lost in the river, leaving her with nothing but a criminal background and a lot of karma to hit her over the head later.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReclusiveArtist: Elise Deauxnim is said to be a popular children's book author, but is so reclusive and mysterious that even the police have a hard time finding out any info on her. [[spoiler: Turns out she's [[DisappearedMom Misty Fey.]]

to:

* ReclusiveArtist: Elise Deauxnim is said to be a popular children's book author, but is so reclusive and mysterious that even the police have a hard time finding out any info on her. [[spoiler: Turns [[spoiler:Turns out she's [[DisappearedMom [[MissingMom Misty Fey.Fey]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OneWayVisor: Godot's mask. [[spoiler: The fact that it glows and can't see red on white both become important plot-points.

to:

* OneWayVisor: Godot's mask. [[spoiler: The [[spoiler:The fact that it glows and can't see red on white both become important plot-points.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* ObsoleteOccupation: One of the witnesses in "Recipe for Turnabout" is Victor Kudo, the last of a family of kimono embroiderers due to kimonos either falling out of fashion (in the Japanese version) or never being in fashion to begin with (in the US version).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


%% * GettingCrapPastThe Radar: Due to overwhelming and persistent misuse, GCPTR is on-page examples only until 01 June 2021. If you are reading this in the future, please check the trope page to make sure your example fits the current definition.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
As requested by the troper who crosswicked this new trope, I'm moving it to Godot's folder on the Characters page.


* LyingByOmission: In Godot's introduction, he claims to have never lost a case, making him appear legendary until he reveals he hasn't ''won'' any case either: It's his first time acting as a prosecutor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cross Wicking a new trope. Couldn't find Godot on the character pages; if he has a folder there, the cross-wick should be moved to his page.

Added DiffLines:

* LyingByOmission: In Godot's introduction, he claims to have never lost a case, making him appear legendary until he reveals he hasn't ''won'' any case either: It's his first time acting as a prosecutor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Mob Debt created

Added DiffLines:

* MobDebt: Glen Eleg, genius programmer, got murdered when a LoanShark wanted to collect on his gambling debt. [[spoiler:The deal was to produce a dangerous virus to pay off the debt.]] The deal went sour when he won the lottery and thus didn't need to hand over the goods.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Trials and Tribulations'' was adapted as the second season of the franchise's [[Anime/AceAttorney anime adaptation]] in 2018.

to:

''Trials and Tribulations'' was adapted as the second season of the franchise's [[Anime/AceAttorney [[Anime/AceAttorney2016 anime adaptation]] in 2018.

Added: 1294

Changed: 943

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DumbassHasAPoint: Larry Butz warning Phoenix that [[spoiler: trying to cross Dusky Bridge while it's on fire is a bad idea]]. He's also very quick to call for help after Phoenix falls in, which even Edgeworth concedes probably saved Phoenix's life.



%%* OneWayVisor: Godot's mask.

to:

%%* * OneWayVisor: Godot's mask.mask. [[spoiler: The fact that it glows and can't see red on white both become important plot-points.



* ReclusiveArtist: Elise Deauxnim is said to be a popular children's book author, but is so reclusive and mysterious that even the police have a hard time finding out any info on her. [[spoiler: Turns out she's [[DisappearedMom Misty Fey.]]



* RedHerring: At the start of [[spoiler:3-5]], Gumshoe speculates that [[spoiler:Godot is MIA because he heard that Phoenix won't be the defense attorney and thus lost interest]]. While this is completely reasonable based on what the player knows of the situation, it's really a smokescreen [[spoiler:to prevent the player from suspecting Godot too early]].
* ReverseWhodunnit: The first game in the series where the first case is ''not'' this, presumably because they didn't really need to assure players that the protagonist was innocent ([[ForegoneConclusion and in a flashback no less]]). The third case mostly plays it straight, though, making it very obvious early on that the fake Phoenix imposter is also the murder.

to:

* RedHerring: RedHerring:
**
At the start of [[spoiler:3-5]], 3-5, Gumshoe speculates that [[spoiler:Godot is MIA because he heard that Phoenix won't be the defense attorney and thus lost interest]]. While this is completely reasonable based on what the player knows of the situation, it's really a smokescreen [[spoiler:to prevent the player from suspecting Godot too early]].
** The note written for Iris in the same case. While it initially seems like it'll part of a hugely important detail later on, since it asks Iris to come to Heavenly Hall unless she wants a secret to be revealed, it turns out it was actually written by [[spoiler: Larry Butz, and he was under the false impression Iris was madly in love with him, which was the "secret". Plus, Iris never actually ended up going.]]
* ReverseWhodunnit: The first game in the series where the first case is ''not'' this, presumably because they didn't really need to assure players that the protagonist was innocent ([[ForegoneConclusion and in a flashback no less]]). The That said, the third case mostly plays it straight, though, making makes it very obvious through silouette early on that the fake Phoenix imposter is also the murder.murderer, playing this more straight.

Added: 226

Changed: 105

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
sorry for the constant edits but I saw that typo and figured I'd might as well add this one from the main Wham Line page


** During the first half of the second trial day, Pheonix comes to a realization when cross-examining Iris.

to:

** Bikini delivers one, which even manages to shock Phoenix:
-->'''Bikini''': [[ThoughtTheyKnewAlready So I guess you already know that]] [[spoiler:Iris is Morgan Fey's daughter.]]
** During the first half of the second trial day, Pheonix Phoenix comes to a realization when cross-examining Iris.

Added: 864

Changed: 501

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NiceJobBreakingItHero: At the beginning of case 3-2, Phoenix easily gets Ron [=DeLite=] off a larceny charge by proving he was somewhere else... only for Godot to come up to him afterward, say there was a murder committed there, and haul Ron off into custody ''again''. What, you thought it ''wouldn't'' be AlwaysMurder? [[spoiler:He was the thief in general, but not in that particular instance. He turned himself in to ensure he could have an alibi for the aforementioned murder. Phoenix was defending him because his wife told Nick he was a delusional {{fanboy}}.]]

to:

* NiceJobBreakingItHero: At the beginning of case 3-2, Phoenix easily gets Ron [=DeLite=] off a larceny charge by proving he was somewhere else... only for Godot to come up to him afterward, say there was a murder committed there, and haul Ron off into custody ''again''. What, you thought it ''wouldn't'' be AlwaysMurder? [[spoiler:He was the thief in general, but not in that particular instance. He turned himself in to ensure he could have an alibi for the aforementioned murder. Phoenix was defending him because his wife told Nick he was a delusional {{fanboy}}. Thug begins a court case where Phoenix has to prove that his defendant ''is'' Mask☆[=DeMasque=] when the previous day he had just disproved it.]]



** Just when it looks like Case 2 is wrapping up, Godot throws a wrench into proceedings:
-->'''Godot''': Early this morning...[[spoiler: the body of Kane Bullard was discovered. ''[...]'' The estimated time of death was 1 AM on October 12th.]]



** During the first half of the second trial day:
--> '''Phoenix''': In fact, it'd be impossible for you to be clueless about this whole thing...[[spoiler: unless you're not really Iris to begin with.]]
** At the end of the game, Iris says that [[spoiler:the girl Phoenix used to date in college wasn't Dahlia, but Iris herself]].

to:

** During a conversation with Edgeworth in the second investigation day:
-->'''Edgeworth''': Like I said, Dahlia isn't connected with this case.\\
'''Phoenix''': Why are you so sure about that?\\
'''Edgeworth''': It's simple. [[spoiler: Dahlia Hawthorne is dead.]]
** During the first half of the second trial day:
--> '''Phoenix''': In
day, Pheonix comes to a realization when cross-examining Iris.
-->'''Phoenix''': "In
fact, it'd be impossible for you to be clueless about this whole thing...[[spoiler: unless you're not really Iris to begin with.]]"
** At the end of the game, Iris gets off one last big one that flips her and her sister's relationship with Phoenix on its head, revealing that [[spoiler: Phoenix had actually been dating Iris back in college.
]]
** At the end of the game, Iris says that [[spoiler:the girl Phoenix used to date in college wasn't Dahlia, but Iris herself]].-->'''Iris''': You and my sister...[[spoiler: [[TwinSwitch you only met twice.]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ReverseWhodunnit: The first game in the series where the first case is ''not'' this, presumably because they didn't really need to assure players that the protagonist was innocent ([[ForegoneConclusion and in a flashback no less]]). The third case mostly plays it straight, though, making it very obvious early on that the fake Phoenix imposter is also the murder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** During the first half of the second trial day:
--> '''Phoenix''': In fact, it'd be impossible for you to be clueless about this whole thing...[[spoiler: unless you're not really Iris to begin with.]]

Added: 892

Removed: 357

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RedHerring: At the start of [[spoiler:3-5]], Gumshoe speculates that [[spoiler:Godot is MIA because he heard that Phoenix won't be the defense attorney and thus lost interest]]. While this is completely reasonable based on what the player knows of the situation, it's really a smokescreen [[spoiler:to prevent the player from suspecting Godot too early]].



* RedHerring: At the start of [[spoiler:3-5]], Gumshoe speculates that [[spoiler:Godot is MIA because he heard that Phoenix won't be the defense attorney and thus lost interest]]. While this is completely reasonable based on what the player knows of the situation, it's really a smokescreen [[spoiler:to prevent the player from suspecting Godot too early]].


Added DiffLines:

* ThrowTheDogABone: Victor Kudo, unfortunately, has to proven to be a senile old man that can't be accurate in what he remembers...in a court of law, effectively making him look like an idiot in front of several people [[spoiler:despite the guy actually telling the truth in what he saw but was tricked in order to be a witness to Elg's fake murder]]. He also says that he's considered an annoyance at home. During the ending, the poor guy reveals that his grandchildren threw him a birthday party that made him so happy that he cried.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RecordedAudioAlibi: Luke Atmey uses a captured surveillance photo of himself as[=Mask=]☆[=DeMasque=] stealing the Kurain Sacred Urn to establish an alibi for the murder of Kane Bullard. It turns out that the photo was actually taken days in advance and the time stamp was manipulated by Atmey, who was responsible for setting up the security measures at the museum.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the final trial segment, you have to present [[spoiler:Godot]]'s profile three times.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Motifs}}: All five cases, even the ones not directly connected to the MythArc, have one or more characters engaging in impersonation:
** 3-1: This seems [[AvertedTrope Averted]] at the start, but at the end of 3-5 it's revealed that [[spoiler:the "Dahlia Hawthorne" Phoenix knew as his girlfriend was actually her twin sister Iris, except for the time they first met in the courthouse and the day of the murder of Doug Swallow.]]
** 3-2: [[spoiler:Luke Atmey]] impersonates Mask☆[=DeMasque=] in order to create an alibi for himself.
** 3-3: Furio Tigre impersonated Phoenix in court, [[spoiler: as well as the victim after the real murder had occurred (while Viola Cadaverini played the role of Maggey Byrde) to create a false witness.]]
** 3-4: [[spoiler:Dahlia Hawthorne]] impersonated the victim at the scene of the crime, and later pretends to be an innocent foreign student in court.
** 3-5: [[spoiler:Dahlia (once again), first channeled by Misty Fey and then by Maya,]] remains under disguise as [[spoiler:her twin Iris]] both during the night of the murder and the second day in court.


Added DiffLines:

* RuleOfThree: Unsurprisingly, this trope reoccurs several times in what is the third game in the series:
** You play as three defense attorneys over the course of the game: Phoenix (in cases 3-2, 3-3, and the second half of 3-5), Mia Fey (in the flashback cases 3-1 and 3-4), and [[spoiler:Edgeworth]] (in the first half of 3-5).
** The second and last trial day of 3-5 takes place over three parts (instead of the usual 1 or 2).
** The [[spoiler:plan to murder Maya Fey]] which gives way to the events of 3-5 involves three conspirators: [[spoiler:Morgan Fey, the mastermind; Pearl Fey, the UnwittingPawn; and the spirit of Dahlia Hawthorne, the intended material executor]]. Likewise, they are thwarted by three accomplices: [[spoiler:Godot, Misty Fey, and Iris]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* KansaiRegionalAccent: Furio Tigre in the Japanese version ([[AccentAdaptation hence his]] [[BrooklynRage Brooklyn accent]] [[AccentAdaptation in the English version]]).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FakeAlibi: Episode two has [[spoiler:the murderer attempt to ConfessToALesserCrime to be at a different location at the time of the crime. He's using time manipulation via evidence tampering to make it work.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Like its two predecessors, the game follows Phoenix Wright, a kind and intelligent yet hapless defense attorney who works to save innocent clients from guilty verdicts. By his side are his loyal assistant, Maya Fey, her older sister Mia, and her cousin Pearl. On the opposite side of the courtroom this time is the mysterious coffee-guzzling prosecutor Godot, who bears a grudge against Phoenix for unknown reasons. Meanwhile, the enigmatic beauty Dahlia Hawthorne seems to recur in the pasts of Phoenix, Edgeworth, and the Feys. The fate of the Fey family hangs in the balance as the last aftershocks of the DL-6 case finally play out.

to:

Like its two predecessors, the game follows Phoenix Wright, a kind and intelligent yet hapless defense attorney who works to save innocent clients from guilty verdicts. By his side are his loyal assistant, Maya Fey, her older sister Mia, Fey and her cousin Pearl.Pearl, who are capable of channeling his deceased mentor, Maya's older sister Mia. On the opposite side of the courtroom this time is the mysterious coffee-guzzling prosecutor Godot, who bears a grudge against Phoenix for unknown reasons. Meanwhile, the enigmatic beauty Dahlia Hawthorne seems to recur in the pasts of Phoenix, Edgeworth, and the Feys. The fate of the Fey family hangs in the balance as the last aftershocks of the DL-6 case finally play out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseArt: In "The Stolen Turnabout", a throwaway line near the start has Maya comment on how cold it is in the basement, with Phoenix responding that it is because the space is air conditioned to protect the art being stored there. Temperature control is indeed an important part of art preservation, but in reality the ideal temperature for that purpose is around normal room temperature, not cold like what Maya suggests.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Initially the GrandFinale of Phoenix's arc, the game was chronologically followed by ''VisualNovel/ApolloJusticeAceAttorney'', which stars a new cast but with Phoenix in a [[SameCharacterButDifferent surprising]] mentor role.

to:

Initially the GrandFinale of Phoenix's arc, the game was [[SeriesFauxnale chronologically followed followed]] by ''VisualNovel/ApolloJusticeAceAttorney'', which stars a new cast but with Phoenix in a [[SameCharacterButDifferent surprising]] mentor role.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CorrectionBait: How [[spoiler:Furio Tigre]] ends up incriminating himself, combined with INeverSaidItWasPoison. [[spoiler:Phoenix presents a green plastic bottle containing the victim's ear medicine, and falsely claims it contained the poison used to commit the murder. Tigre immediately points out that the actual poison bottle was made of brown glass, something he shouldn't have known unless he was the one who used the poison.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MassiveMultiplayerScam: The fourth case is about how a cop's sister is kidnapped by her boyfriend, asking for a ransom of an expensive diamond of their father's at a mountain river. It was all staged in order to sell the diamond and split the millions of dollars amongst themselves. However, all of THAT was a scam; the sister planned this all along and jumped into a river with the diamond, keeping it for herself. (Until it was lost in the river, leaving her with nothing but a criminal background and a lot of karma to hit her over the head later.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MayItNeverHappenAgain: After Dahlia Hawthorne is exorcised near the end of the final trial, everyone present agrees that Dahlia must never be summoned again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DevelopersForesight: By this point in the series it's been well established that presenting correct evidence causes any music playing at the time to stop, while incorrect evidence lets the music keep running with whomever you're presenting the evidence to shrug it off. Anyone who used this for {{save scumming}} are in for a rude awakening [[spoiler:when the final presentation of evidence, an instant game over if you're wrong, deliberately ignores this and behaves as if you've presented the wrong piece of evidence with the music still playing and Godot having the same dialogue no matter what, only deviating after he's done talking if you're correct.]]

Top