Follow TV Tropes

Following

History FanonDiscontinuity / Literature

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Many fans consider ''Literature/{{Eclipse|2007}}'' the last book of the series, to the point that there's a Website/LiveJournal community about it, due to disliking how ''Literature/BreakingDawn'' ends the story. The main issues include who gets paired with who (Team Jacob were naturally disappointed that Bella chooses Edward and even fans who didn't ship Jacob/Bella weren't too keen on him [[spoiler:imprinting on Bella and Edward's infant daughter]] because of the icky implications), the plot revolving entirely around [[spoiler:Edward and Bella having a half-vampire baby]] following the first part and the conclusion being viewed as anti-climatic.

to:

** Many fans consider ''Literature/{{Eclipse|2007}}'' the last book of the series, to the point that there's a Website/LiveJournal Platform/LiveJournal community about it, due to disliking how ''Literature/BreakingDawn'' ends the story. The main issues include who gets paired with who (Team Jacob were naturally disappointed that Bella chooses Edward and even fans who didn't ship Jacob/Bella weren't too keen on him [[spoiler:imprinting on Bella and Edward's infant daughter]] because of the icky implications), the plot revolving entirely around [[spoiler:Edward and Bella having a half-vampire baby]] following the first part and the conclusion being viewed as anti-climatic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/{{Worm}}'': Many fans ignore the existence of the sequel, ''Literature/{{Ward}}'', for various reasons.
** TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt was the finale for ''Worm'', which was already a dark story, so everything afterwards can veer into TooBleakStoppedCaring far more easily than intended.
** Antares is generally perceived as having weaker team dynamics than the Undersiders, and in some cases come off as totally unsympathetic ([[spoiler:which is especially impressive given that one of the Undersiders was confirmed to be a rapist and showed no remorse over said actions]]).
** Some fans wrote off the story once it was revealed that protagonist was an OlderAndWiser Glory Girl, as Victoria's initial showing was so poor that no one wanted to give her a chance to do better.
** Probably the biggest facing ''Ward'' is that ''Worm'''s ending was considered such that a sequel ''wasn't seen as necessary'' - people felt it should be open ended.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
correcting errors


** The fandom tends to treat the backstory of Masterharper Robinton revealed in ''Masterharper of Pern'' like a pizza menu: Some bits (mostly involving his father, Petiron) are mostly accepted. Some bits are accepted by some, ignored by others (his TheLostLenore wife, his relationship with Madara) and others are near-universally ignored [[spoiler: (the fact that Dimo is Robinton and Madara's son).]]

to:

** The fandom tends to treat the backstory of Masterharper Robinton revealed in ''Masterharper of Pern'' like a pizza menu: Some bits (mostly involving his father, Petiron) are mostly accepted. Some bits are accepted by some, ignored by others (his TheLostLenore wife, his relationship with Madara) Silvina) and others are near-universally ignored [[spoiler: (the fact that Dimo Camo is Robinton and Madara's Silvina's son).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Many fans consider ''Literature/{{Eclipse|2007}}'' the last book of the series, to the point that there's a Website/LiveJournal community about it, due to disliking how ''Literature/BreakingDawn'' ends the story.

to:

** Many fans consider ''Literature/{{Eclipse|2007}}'' the last book of the series, to the point that there's a Website/LiveJournal community about it, due to disliking how ''Literature/BreakingDawn'' ends the story. The main issues include who gets paired with who (Team Jacob were naturally disappointed that Bella chooses Edward and even fans who didn't ship Jacob/Bella weren't too keen on him [[spoiler:imprinting on Bella and Edward's infant daughter]] because of the icky implications), the plot revolving entirely around [[spoiler:Edward and Bella having a half-vampire baby]] following the first part and the conclusion being viewed as anti-climatic.

Added: 1511

Changed: 271

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/FiftyShadesOfGrey'': There's a growing group of readers who like to pretend that the series consists of only the first book, ignoring ''Fifty Shades Darker'' and ''Fifty Shades Freed''. The book ends with Anastasia realizing that she cannot fulfill Christian's [=BDSM=] needs and leaving him.

to:

* ''Literature/FiftyShadesOfGrey'': ''Literature/FiftyShadesOfGrey'':
**
There's a growing group of readers who like to pretend that the series consists of only the first book, ignoring ''Fifty Shades Darker'' and ''Fifty Shades Freed''. The book ends with Anastasia realizing that she cannot fulfill Christian's [=BDSM=] needs and leaving him.him, thus putting an end to their dysfunctional relationship. The first book could then potentially be viewed as a flawed yet interesting erotic drama, in a similar vein as ''Film/NineAndAHalfWeeks''. However, in the sequel Ana almost immediately take Christian back, with the rest of the trilogy chronicling the ups and downs of their romance, which largely remains highly dysfunctional and arguably abusive (though the series doesn't often treat it as such).
** Even some legitimate fans of ''Fifty Shades'' prefer to ignore the trilogy retelling the series from [[PerspectiveFlip Christian’s viewpoint]]; while it doesn’t really add anything new to the story (with some calling it a cash grab), the really contentious part is that the retelling makes Christian come off as extremely creepy and unhinged; while his behaviour in the original trilogy is certainly questionable, the retelling made it difficult for fans to view him as an appealing love interest at all because ''Grey'', ''Darker'' and ''Freed'' make him out to be even worse than when he’s described through Ana’s eyes. For readers who already didn't much like Christian, this trilogy often only reinforced their opinion rather than presenting him in a more sympathetic light.

Added: 252

Changed: 823

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Many fans consider ''Eclipse'' the last book of the series, to the point that there's a Website/LiveJournal community about it.
** Some casual fans who like the first book consider it the only book of the series.

to:

** Many fans consider ''Eclipse'' ''Literature/{{Eclipse|2007}}'' the last book of the series, to the point that there's a Website/LiveJournal community about it.
it, due to disliking how ''Literature/BreakingDawn'' ends the story.
** Some casual fans who like the [[Literature/Twilight2005 first book book]] consider it the only book of the series.series (it's generally considered the best of the series due to being a fairly straight-forward teen ParanormalRomance, while the sequels get a lot more contentious, dragged-out and downright bizarre).



* [[Creator/VCAndrews Virginia "V.C." Andrews]]: Fans are often split on books after her death. Literature/FlowersInTheAttic series is a pure example. The prequel was ghost written, causing some to contest it, although it was outlined by Andrews.

to:

* ''Literature/TheVampireDiaries'': A portion of the fans refuse to acknowledge anything beyond the ''Return'' trilogy as canon, due to the fact the original author Creator/LJSmith was fired by the publisher and replaced with a ghostwriter (allegedly due to Smith and the publisher disagreeing on the direction of the series).
* [[Creator/VCAndrews Virginia "V.C." Andrews]]: Fans are often split on books after her death. Literature/FlowersInTheAttic
** ''Literature/FlowersInTheAttic''
series is a pure example. The prequel was ghost written, causing some to contest it, although it was outlined by Andrews.

Added: 804

Removed: 796

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Many fans despise the ending of the final ''Literature/TheDreamers2003'' series book ''The Younger Gods'' by Creator/DavidEddings, and so quite a few just ignore the book in its entirety. The biggest issue is that the plot of the series concerned fighting an enemy that wants world domination and is constantly creating new servants in new forms. At the end of the last book, the ''real'' creator gods (which came out of nowhere) go back in time and make the enemy infertile -- which nullifies ''the entire series''. As in, once they're done, the book's events change so that while the gods remember what had happened, nobody else does, because to them, it had never happened, and everyone is back where they started. Many fans found this extremely unsatisfying and so pretend it didn't happen.


Added DiffLines:

* Many fans of Creator/DavidEddings' ''Literature/{{The Dreamers|2003}}'' series despise the ending of the final book, ''The Younger Gods'', and so just ignore the book in its entirety. The biggest issue is that the plot of the series concerns fighting an enemy that wants world domination and is constantly creating new servants in new forms. At the end of the last book, the ''real'' creator gods ([[AssPull which came out of nowhere]]) go back in time and make the enemy infertile -- which nullifies ''the entire series''. As in, once they're done, the book's events change so that while the gods remember what had happened, nobody else does, because to them, it had never happened, and everyone is back where they started. Many fans found this extremely unsatisfying and so pretend it didn't happen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/EarthsChildren'': Many fans consider the fourth book to be the last. Given that the first four books (''The Clan of the Cave Bear'', ''The Valley of Horses'', ''The Mammoth Hunters'' and ''The Plains of Passage'') were published in 1980, 1982, 1985, and 1990, and it was not until after a lengthy SequelGap -- then another -- that books five (''The Shelters of Stone'') and six (''The Land of Painted Caves'') came out in 2002 and 2011, it's easy for long-time fans to keep thinking of the fourth book as the final one (the fact many fans believe {{Sequelitis}} kicked in hard with these installments contributes). While ''ThePlains of Passage'' doesn't tie up ''every'' plot point, it does feature a happy conclusion to one of the main storylines of the first four books, ending with Ayla and Jondalar [[spoiler:arriving safely at the Ninth Cave of the Zelandonii, intending to get married and Ayla having learned [[BabiesEverAfter she's pregnant with Jondalar's child]]]].

to:

* ''Literature/EarthsChildren'': Many fans consider the fourth book to be the last. Given that the first four books (''The Clan of the Cave Bear'', ''The Valley of Horses'', ''The Mammoth Hunters'' and ''The Plains of Passage'') were published in 1980, 1982, 1985, and 1990, and it was not until after a lengthy SequelGap -- then another -- that books five (''The Shelters of Stone'') and six (''The Land of Painted Caves'') came out in 2002 and 2011, it's easy for long-time fans to keep thinking of the fourth book as the final one (the fact many fans believe {{Sequelitis}} kicked in hard with these installments contributes). While ''ThePlains ''The Plains of Passage'' doesn't tie up ''every'' plot point, it does feature a happy conclusion to one of the main storylines of the first four books, ending with Ayla and Jondalar [[spoiler:arriving safely at the Ninth Cave of the Zelandonii, intending to get married and Ayla having learned [[BabiesEverAfter she's pregnant with Jondalar's child]]]].

Added: 2502

Changed: 324

Removed: 2237

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/TheChroniclesOfAmber'': Fans and Creator/RogerZelazny's friends (like Creator/GeorgeRRMartin and Creator/NeilGaiman) usually don't want to talk about John Gregory Betancourt's ''Dawn of Amber'' prequels. Setting aside the relative quality of the works, one of their reasons is that Zelazny, while having no problem with writing for SharedUniverse[[note]]He contributed to ''Literature/WildCards'' and even created one shared world himself[[/note]] had said that ''Amber'' was his and he never wanted to turn it into a franchise. After his death, the literary agent of his estate interpreted this as meaning that [[MoneyDearBoy Zelazny desperately wanted somebody else to write more Amber books]].



* ''Franchise/ConanTheBarbarian'':
** Some fans ignore ''Conan the Bold'' because it does not fit in with the other stories, due to Conan crossing most of Hyboria in a short period of time.
** Many fans ignore the ''[[Film/ConanTheBarbarian1982 Conan the Barbarian]]'' and ''[[Film/ConanTheDestroyer Conan the Destroyer]]'' novelizations, or treat them as alternate continuities because they contain details that conflict with the other stories (notably, the films themselves take place in their own continuity separate from the books)
* ''Literature/ACourtOfThornsAndRoses'': A portion of the fandom prefers not to read beyond the original trilogy due to disliking the direction the later books take, in particular Feyre undergoing BadassDecay, certain characters coming off as OOC and/or becoming unlikable in these readers' eyes, Rhysand's questionable treatment of Feyre in the fifth book, and the ever-increasing number of sex scenes (which some readers find distracting more than anything).
* Many fans despise the ending of the final ''Literature/TheDreamers2003'' series book ''The Younger Gods'' by Creator/DavidEddings, and so quite a few just ignore the book in its entirety. The biggest issue is that the plot of the series concerned fighting an enemy that wants world domination and is constantly creating new servants in new forms. At the end of the last book, the ''real'' creator gods (which came out of nowhere) go back in time and make the enemy infertile -- which nullifies ''the entire series''. As in, once they're done, the book's events change so that while the gods remember what had happened, nobody else does, because to them, it had never happened, and everyone is back where they started. Many fans found this extremely unsatisfying and so pretend it didn't happen.



* ''Franchise/ConanTheBarbarian'': ''Conan the Bold'' does not fit in with the other stories, due to Conan crossing most of Hyboria in a short period of time. The ''[[Film/ConanTheBarbarian1982 Conan the Barbarian]]'' and ''[[Film/ConanTheDestroyer Conan the Destroyer]]'' novelizations do not fit and contain details that conflict with other stories.
* ''Literature/ACourtOfThornsAndRoses'': A portion of the fandom prefers not to read beyond the original trilogy due to disliking the direction the later books take, in particular Feyre undergoing BadassDecay, certain characters coming off as OOC and/or becoming unlikable in these readers' eyes, Rhysand's questionable treatment of Feyre in the fifth book, and the ever-increasing number of sex scenes (which some readers find distracting more than anything).
* Creator/DavidEddings: Fans despise the ending of ''Literature/TheDreamers2003'' book ''The Younger Gods'', and so quite a few just ignore the book in its entirety.[[note]]The plot of the series concerned fighting an enemy that wants world domination and is constantly creating new servants in new forms. At the end of the last book, the ''real'' creator gods (which came out of nowhere) go back in time and make the enemy infertile -- which nullifies ''the entire series''. As in, once they're done, the book's events change so that while the gods remember what had happened, nobody else does, because to them, it had never happened, and everyone is back where they started. ''Nobody'' liked that ending.[[/note]]



* ''Literature/{{Dexter}}'': Many fans prefer to ignore ''Dexter in the Dark'' as much as possible, because [[spoiler:the Dark Passenger is revealed to be a supernatural entity, rather than a part of Dexter's mind]].

to:

* ''Literature/{{Dexter}}'': Many fans prefer to ignore ''Dexter in the Dark'' as much as possible, because [[spoiler:the Dark Passenger is revealed to be a supernatural entity, rather than a part of Dexter's mind]].mind]], which readers perceived as a weird direction for the series to take (the first two books are fairly grounded psychological thrillers with nothing overtly supernatural). Notably, the following books in the series mostly ignore this plot point too, so it appears the author agreed with the fans' assessment.



* ''Literature/TheChroniclesOfAmber'': Fans and Creator/RogerZelazny's friends (like Creator/GeorgeRRMartin and Creator/NeilGaiman) usually don't want to talk about John Gregory Betancourt's ''Dawn of Amber'' prequels. Setting aside the relative quality of the works, one of their reasons is that Zelazny, while having no problem with writing for SharedUniverse[[note]]He contributed to ''Literature/WildCards'' and even created one shared world himself[[/note]] had said that ''Amber'' was his and he never wanted to turn it into a franchise. After his death, the literary agent of his estate interpreted this as meaning that [[MoneyDearBoy Zelazny desperately wanted somebody else to write more Amber books]].



* ''Literature/FoundationSeries'': Many fans of ''Literature/TheFoundationTrilogy'' restrict the canon of the series to just that trilogy, excluding the {{Sequel}}s and {{Prequel}}s, including those of ''Literature/TheSecondFoundationTrilogy''.

to:

%%ZCE * ''Literature/FoundationSeries'': Many fans of ''Literature/TheFoundationTrilogy'' restrict the canon of the series to just that trilogy, excluding the {{Sequel}}s and {{Prequel}}s, including those of ''Literature/TheSecondFoundationTrilogy''.



* ''Literature/GoldenWitchbreed'': Fans insist that there are no sequels.

to:

%%ZCE * ''Literature/GoldenWitchbreed'': Fans insist that there are no sequels.



* ''Literature/MaximumRide'': A few fans have ignored the TrilogyCreep by deciding that only the first three books are canon.

to:

%%ZCE * ''Literature/MaximumRide'': A few fans have ignored the TrilogyCreep by deciding that only the first three books are canon.

Top