[002]
MeikyuButterfly
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I take issue with the current way the entry is written. Not only have there been many analyses of the game that point out why exactly almost all of these characters\' portrayals in the game are accurate and make sense in context with their changed situation, you don\'t even need such analysis to see that many of the claims above are flat out incorrect; Junpei has always been portrayed as a pervert who randomly drags his pals on date hunts and willingly tricks them into spying on bathing girls with them (both of this happened in the original Persona 3), Akihiko was literally \'\'introduced\'\' as a blood knights, this aspect of his character only ending up getting toned down in P3 due to his character falling entirely out of focus when the plot marched on, Marie has a whole sidequest dedicated to her, Theodore\'\'s relationship to his sisters is portrayed exactly the same way it had been portrayed in Japanese supplementary material ever since the character was first introduced, etc. etc. etc. the only points that remain standing once you dispel everything that\'s conjunction, subjective impression or flat-out incorrect are the exaggeration of Chie\'s and Akihiko\'s diets and Teddie\'s flirting, and even with that, Teddie has plenty moments in the game where the claim listed above is simply untrue. Even the complaint about Elizabeth\'s personality doesn\'t stand, since she has been portrayed this exact way in every media that came out after P3FES, meaning the change is unrelated to Persona Q. In other words: this trope example is far longer than it has any right to be and colored by subjective ideas that should have no place in the main tab.
to:
I take issue with the current way the entry is written. Not only have there been many analyses of the game that point out why exactly almost all of these characters\\\' portrayals in the game are accurate and make sense in context with their changed situation, you don\\\'t even need such analysis to see that many of the claims above are flat out incorrect; Junpei has always been portrayed as a pervert who randomly drags his pals on date hunts and willingly tricks them into spying on bathing girls with them (both of this happened in the original Persona 3), Akihiko was literally \\\'\\\'introduced\\\'\\\' as a blood knights, this aspect of his character only ending up getting toned down in P3 due to his character falling entirely out of focus when the plot marched on, Marie has a whole sidequest dedicated to her, Theodore\\\'\\\'s relationship to his sisters is portrayed exactly the same way it had been portrayed in Japanese supplementary material ever since the character was first introduced, etc. etc. etc. the only points that remain standing once you dispel everything that\\\'s conjunction, subjective impression or flat-out incorrect are the exaggeration of Chie\\\'s and Akihiko\\\'s diets and Teddie\\\'s flirting, and even with that, Teddie has plenty moments in the game where the claim listed above is simply untrue. Even the complaint about Elizabeth\\\'s personality doesn\\\'t stand, since she has been portrayed this exact way in every media that came out after P3FES, meaning the change is unrelated to Persona Q. In other words: this trope example is far longer than it has any right to be and colored by subjective ideas that should have no place in the main tab. Almost none of what happened is actual \\\"Flanderization\\\" as much as just players being surprised that characters don\\\'t act exactly as they thought they\\\'d act based on their own impressions. If you want to dispute this, I can give screenshots from all versions of P3 and P4, side by side with screens from PQ, to back up my claims and show that these characters have by far not been \\\"changed\\\" as drastically as this entry would make people think.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I take issue with the current way the entry is written. Not only have there been many analyses of the game that point out why exactly almost all of these characters\' portrayals in the game are accurate and make sense in context with their changed situation, you don\'t even need such analysis to see that many of the claims above are flat out incorrect; Junpei has always been portrayed as a pervert who randomly drags his pals on date hunts and willingly tricks them into spying on bathing girls with them (both of this happened in the original Persona 3), Akihiko was literally \'\'introduced\'\' as a blood knights, this aspect of his character only ending up getting toned down in P3 due to his character falling entirely out of focus when the plot marched on, Marie has a whole sunburst dedicated to her, Theodore\'\'s relationship to his sisters is portrayed exactly the same way it had been portrayed in Japanese supplementary material ever since the character was first introduced, etc. etc. etc. the only points that remain standing once you dispel everything that\'s conjunction, subjective impression or flat-out incorrect are the exaggeration of Chie\'s and Akihiko\'s diets and Teddie\'s flirting, and even with that, Teddie has plenty moments in the game where the claim listed above is simply untrue. Even the complaint about Elizabeth\'s personality doesn\'t stand, since she has been portrayed this exact way in every media that came out after P3FES, meaning the change is unrelated to Persona Q. In other words: this trope example is far longer than it has any right to be and colored by subjective ideas that should have no place in the main tab.
to:
I take issue with the current way the entry is written. Not only have there been many analyses of the game that point out why exactly almost all of these characters\\\' portrayals in the game are accurate and make sense in context with their changed situation, you don\\\'t even need such analysis to see that many of the claims above are flat out incorrect; Junpei has always been portrayed as a pervert who randomly drags his pals on date hunts and willingly tricks them into spying on bathing girls with them (both of this happened in the original Persona 3), Akihiko was literally \\\'\\\'introduced\\\'\\\' as a blood knights, this aspect of his character only ending up getting toned down in P3 due to his character falling entirely out of focus when the plot marched on, Marie has a whole sidequest dedicated to her, Theodore\\\'\\\'s relationship to his sisters is portrayed exactly the same way it had been portrayed in Japanese supplementary material ever since the character was first introduced, etc. etc. etc. the only points that remain standing once you dispel everything that\\\'s conjunction, subjective impression or flat-out incorrect are the exaggeration of Chie\\\'s and Akihiko\\\'s diets and Teddie\\\'s flirting, and even with that, Teddie has plenty moments in the game where the claim listed above is simply untrue. Even the complaint about Elizabeth\\\'s personality doesn\\\'t stand, since she has been portrayed this exact way in every media that came out after P3FES, meaning the change is unrelated to Persona Q. In other words: this trope example is far longer than it has any right to be and colored by subjective ideas that should have no place in the main tab.
