Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History YMMV / GameOfThrones

Go To

Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
* After Tyrion [[spoiler: does something irrational in reaction to Shae\'s betrayal and demands a trial by combat, only for his champion Oberyn to lose, Jaime breaks him out of his cell. Jaime tells him Varys will be helping him escape.]] What does Tyrion decide to do? Something irrational a \'\'second\'\' time, of course. [[spoiler: He risks his second chance at life to go and confront his father. Tyrion even illogically asks Tywin why he sentenced his own son to death... Aforementioned sentence was dependent on the outcome of a trial by combat that Tyrion demanded and not Tywin\'s wishes.]]
to:
* After Tyrion [[spoiler: does something irrational in reaction to Shae\\\'s betrayal and demands a trial by combat, only for his champion Oberyn to lose, Jaime breaks him out of his cell. Jaime tells him Varys will be helping him escape.]] What does Tyrion decide to do? Something irrational a \\\'\\\'second\\\'\\\' time, of course. [[spoiler: He risks his second chance at life to go and confront his father. Tyrion even illogically asks Tywin why he sentenced his own son to death... Aforementioned sentence was not dependent on Tywin\\\'s wishes, but on the outcome of the trial by combat that Tyrion demanded.]]
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
* After Tyrion [[spoiler: does something irrational in reaction to Shae\'s betrayal and demands a trial by combat, only for his champion Oberyn to lose, Jaime breaks him out of his cell. Jaime tells him Varys will be helping him escape.]] What does Tyrion decide to do? Something irrational a \'\'second\'\' time, of course. [[spoiler: He risks his second chance at life to go and confront his father. Tyrion even illogically asks Tywin why he sentenced his own son to death. Said sentence was dependent on the outcome of a trial by combat Tyrion demanded and not Tywin\'s wishes.]]
to:
* After Tyrion [[spoiler: does something irrational in reaction to Shae\\\'s betrayal and demands a trial by combat, only for his champion Oberyn to lose, Jaime breaks him out of his cell. Jaime tells him Varys will be helping him escape.]] What does Tyrion decide to do? Something irrational a \\\'\\\'second\\\'\\\' time, of course. [[spoiler: He risks his second chance at life to go and confront his father. Tyrion even illogically asks Tywin why he sentenced his own son to death... Aforementioned sentence was dependent on the outcome of a trial by combat that Tyrion demanded and not Tywin\\\'s wishes.]]
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
* In \
to:
* After Tyrion [[spoiler: does something irrational in reaction to Shae\\\'s betrayal and demands a trial by combat, only for his champion Oberyn to lose, Jaime breaks him out of his cell. Jaime tells him Varys will be helping him escape.]] What does Tyrion decide to do? Something irrational a \\\'\\\'second\\\'\\\' time, of course. [[spoiler: He risks his second chance at life to go and confront his father. Tyrion even illogically asks Tywin why he sentenced his own son to death. Said sentence was dependent on the outcome of a trial by combat Tyrion demanded and not Tywin\\\'s wishes.]]
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
Heck, asking Tywin why he sentenced Tyrion to die was probably the dumbest line of dialogue written for Tyrion. His fighter loses the trial, and he actually asks his father why he sentenced his own son (who demanded a trial by combat and lost) to death? Just that question alone deserves a WhatAnIdiot entry, but I digress...
to:
Heck, asking Tywin why he sentenced Tyrion to die was probably the dumbest line of dialogue written for Tyrion. His fighter loses the trial, and he actually asks his father why he sentenced his own son (who demanded a trial by combat and lost) to death? Just that question alone deserves a WhatAnIdiot entry.
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
* In \
to:
* In \\\"The Children\\\", after Tyrion [[spoiler: does something irrational in reaction to Shae\\\'s betrayal and demands a trial by combat, only for his champion Oberyn to lose, Jaime breaks him out of his cell. Jaime tells him Varys will be waiting for him behind a door.]] What does Tyrion decide to do? Something irrational a \\\'\\\'second\\\'\\\' time, of course. [[spoiler: He risks his second chance at life to go and confront his father. Tyrion even asks Tywin why he sentenced his own son to death... A sentence dependent on the outcome of a trial by combat Tyrion demanded.]]
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
* In \
to:
* In \\\"The Children\\\", after Tyrion [[spoiler: does something irrational in reaction to Shae\\\'s betrayal and demands a trial by combat, only for his champion Oberyn to lose, Jaime breaks him out of his cell. Jaime tells him Varys will be waiting for him behind a door.]] What does Tyrion decide to do? Something irrational a \\\'\\\'second\\\'\\\' time, of course. [[spoiler: He risks his second chance at life to go and confront his father. Tyrion even asks Tywin why he sentenced his own son to death... A sentence dependent on the outcome of a trial by combat Tyrion demanded.]]
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
* In \
to:
* In \\\"The Children\\\", after Tyrion [[spoiler: does something irrational in reaction to Shae\\\'s betrayal and demands a trial by combat, only for his champion Oberyn to lose, Jaime breaks him out of his cell. Jaime tells him Varys will be waiting for him behind a door.]] What does Tyrion decide to do? Something irrational a \\\'\\\'second\\\'\\\' time, of course. [[spoiler: He risks his second chance at life to go and confront his father.]]
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
Heck, asking Tywin why he sentenced Tyrion to die was probably the dumbest line of dialogue written for Tyrion. His fighter loses the trial, and he actually asks his father why he sentenced his own son who demanded a trial by combat and lost to death? Just that question alone deserves a WhatAnIdiot entry, but I digress...
to:
Heck, asking Tywin why he sentenced Tyrion to die was probably the dumbest line of dialogue written for Tyrion. His fighter loses the trial, and he actually asks his father why he sentenced his own son (who demanded a trial by combat and lost) to death? Just that question alone deserves a WhatAnIdiot entry, but I digress...
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
* In \
to:
* In \\\"The Children\\\", after Tyrion [[spoiler: does something irrational in reaction to Shae\\\'s betrayal and demands a trial by combat, only for his champion Oberyn to lose, Jaime breaks him out of his cell. Jaime tells him Varys will be waiting for him behind a door.]] What does Tyrion decide to do? Something irrational a \\\'\\\'second\\\'\\\' time, of course. [[spoiler: He risks his second chance at life to go and confront his father.]] This was better explained in the books.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
His irrational actions are the exact opposite of a character flaw. This is Tyrion Lannister we\'re talking about here. He only makes irrational decisions under extreme circumstances, which is why after losing his trial by combat and awaiting his execution, facing his own impending mortality in the face and being scared, and being offered by Jaime and Varys one last chance at freedom, his decision to delay and jeopardize that chance to go and confront his father comes off as incredibly stupid. It \'\'is\'\' a bizarre decision without the motivation from the books. Heck, asking Tywin why he sentenced Tyrion to die was probably the dumbest line of dialogue written for Tyrion.
to:
His irrational actions are the exact opposite of a character flaw. This is Tyrion Lannister we\\\'re talking about here. He only makes irrational decisions under extreme circumstances, which is why after losing his trial by combat and awaiting his execution, facing his own impending mortality in the face and being scared, and being offered by Jaime and Varys one last chance at freedom, his decision to delay and jeopardize that chance to go and confront his father comes off as incredibly stupid. It \\\'\\\'is\\\'\\\' a bizarre decision without the motivation from the books.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
* In \
to:
Heck, asking Tywin why he sentenced Tyrion to die was probably the dumbest line of dialogue written for Tyrion. His fighter loses the trial, and he actually asks his father why he sentenced his own son who demanded a trial by combat and lost to death? Just that question alone deserves a WhatAnIdiot entry, but I digress...

* In \\\"The Children\\\", after Tyrion [[spoiler: does something irrational in reaction to Shae\\\'s betrayal and demands a trial by combat, only for his champion Oberyn to lose, Jaime breaks him out of his cell. Jaime tells him Varys will be waiting for him behind a door.]] What does Tyrion decide to do? Something irrational a \\\'\\\'second\\\'\\\' time, of course. [[spoiler: He risks his second chance at life to go and confront his father.]] This was better explained in the books.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
His irrational actions are the exact opposite of a character flaw. This is Tyrion Lannister we\'re talking about here. He only makes irrational decisions under extreme circumstances, which is why after losing his trial by combat and awaiting his execution, facing his own impending mortality in the face and being scared, and being offered by Jaime and Varys one last chance at freedom, his decision to delay and jeopardize that chance to go and confront his father comes off as incredibly stupid. It \'\'is\'\' a bizarre decision without the motivation from the books.
to:
His irrational actions are the exact opposite of a character flaw. This is Tyrion Lannister we\\\'re talking about here. He only makes irrational decisions under extreme circumstances, which is why after losing his trial by combat and awaiting his execution, facing his own impending mortality in the face and being scared, and being offered by Jaime and Varys one last chance at freedom, his decision to delay and jeopardize that chance to go and confront his father comes off as incredibly stupid. It \\\'\\\'is\\\'\\\' a bizarre decision without the motivation from the books. Heck, asking Tywin why he sentenced Tyrion to die was probably the dumbest line of dialogue written for Tyrion.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
* In \
to:
* In \\\"The Children\\\", after Tyrion [[spoiler: does something irrational in reaction to Shae\\\'s betrayal and demands a trial by combat, only for his champion Oberyn to lose, Jaime breaks him out of his cell. Jaime tells him Varys will be waiting for him behind a door.]] What does Tyrion decide to do? Something irrational a \\\'\\\'second\\\'\\\' time, of course. [[spoiler: He risks his second chance at life to go and confront his father.]] This was better explained in the books.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
* In \
to:
* In \\\"The Children\\\", after Tyrion [[spoiler: does something irrational in reaction to Shae\\\'s betrayal and demands a trial by combat, only for his champion Oberyn to lose, Jaime breaks him out of his cell. Jaime tells him Varys will be waiting for him behind a door.]] What does Tyrion decide to do? Something irrational a \\\'\\\'second\\\'\\\' time, of course. [[spoiler: He risks his second chance at life to go and confront his father.]] This was better explained in the books.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
* In \
to:
* In \\\"The Children\\\", after Tyrion [[spoiler: does something irrational in reaction to Shae\\\'s betrayal and demands a trial by combat, only for his champion Oberyn to lose, Jaime breaks him out of his cell. Jaime tells him Varys will be waiting for him behind a door.]] What does Tyrion decide to do? Something irrational a second time, of course. [[spoiler: He risks his second chance at life to go and confront his father.]]
Top