Discussion History Main / OnlyAModel

I\\\'m sorry I was so hasty with the deletions, it just didn\\\'t seem like anyone was debating. 74.97.180.112 made good defense of theirs, but the other responses were just \\\"It\\\'s my opinion!\\\" and \\\"A lot of people feel that way.\\\" rather than a rebuttal or even acknowledgment of the concerns. A lot of these are reading like \\\"Episode 5 is a [[EmphasizeEverything MAJOR]] deconstruction of bananas because there were bananas in it. Sometimes you make it into banana bread and sometimes you slip on the peel.\\\" It reminds me of the HowNotToWriteAnExample page: \\\"Deconstructed in Your Show: Your Show used this trope, but because it\\\'s Your Show, it\\\'s a deconstruction.\\\"

I have a problem with the \\\"My show is edgier and more subversive than YourShow!\\\" vibe on this page, especially when people break out the \\\"It\\\'s ironic.\\\" defense because, however unintentional, that reads like \\\"You\\\'re just too dumb to get it.\\\" It comes off as pretentious, especially since most of the attitude about everything this show is and is going to be was formed before the premiere of the second episode. This fandom moved \\\'\\\'really\\\'\\\' fast, and the early pilot and long hiatus did not help things.

I actually wasn\\\'t aware that the VerySpecialEpisode episodes were considered a parody by \\\'\\\'anyone\\\'\\\'. I frequent Television Without Pity, the official Glee forums, IMDB, the After Elton recaps, and whatever other recaps I can find, and the majority opinion is that they\\\'re playing the VerySpecialEpisode pretty straight. That part should at least be rewritten to say that there is some debate over whether it\\\'s a send up at all, because right now it just says \\\"Home\\\" is the only one that\\\'s even questionable.

I\\\'m sorry I was so hasty with the deletions, it just didn\\\'t seem like anyone was debating. 74.97.180.112 made good defense of theirs, but the other responses were just \\\"It\\\'s my opinion!\\\" and \\\"A lot of people feel that way.\\\" rather than a rebuttal or even acknowledgment of my concerns. A lot of these are reading like \\\"Episode 5 is a [[EmphasizeEverything MAJOR]] deconstruction of bananas because there were bananas in it. Sometimes you make it into banana bread and sometimes you slip on the peel.\\\" It reminds me of the HowNotToWriteAnExample page: \\\"Deconstructed in Your Show: Your Show used this trope, but because it\\\'s Your Show, it\\\'s a deconstruction.\\\"

I have a problem with the \\\"My show is edgier and more subversive than YourShow!\\\" vibe on this page, especially when people break out the \\\"It\\\'s ironic.\\\" defense because, however unintentional, that reads like \\\"You\\\'re just too dumb to get it.\\\" It comes off as pretentious, especially since most of the attitude about everything this show is and is going to be was formed before the premiere of the second episode. This fandom moved \\\'\\\'really\\\'\\\' fast, and the early pilot and long hiatus did not help things.

I actually wasn\\\'t aware that the VerySpecialEpisode episodes were considered a parody by \\\'\\\'anyone\\\'\\\'. I frequent Television Without Pity, the official Glee forums, IMDB, the After Elton recaps, and whatever other recaps I can find, and the majority opinion is that they\\\'re playing the VerySpecialEpisode pretty straight. That part should at least be rewritten to say that there is some debate over whether it\\\'s a send up at all, because right now it just says \\\"Home\\\" is the only one that\\\'s even questionable.

I\\\'m sorry I was so hasty with the deletions, it just didn\\\'t seem like anyone was debating. 74.97.180.112 made good defense of theirs, but the other responses were just \\\"It\\\'s my opinion!\\\" and \\\"A lot of people feel that way.\\\" rather than a rebuttal or even acknowledgment of my concerns. A lot of these are reading like \\\"Episode 5 is a MAJOR deconstruction of bananas because there were bananas in it. Sometimes you make it into banana bread and sometimes you slip on the peel.\\\" It reminds me of the HowNotToWriteAnExample page: \\\"Deconstructed in Your Show: Your Show used this trope, but because it\\\'s Your Show, it\\\'s a deconstruction.\\\"

I have a problem with the \\\"My show is edgier and more subversive than YourShow!\\\" vibe on this page, especially when people break out the \\\'It\\\'s \\\'ironic\\\'\\\'.\\\" defense because, however unintentional, that reads like \\\"You\\\'re just too dumb to get it.\\\" It comes off as pretentious, especially since most of the attitude about everything this show is and is going to be was formed before the premiere of the second episode.

I actually wasn\\\'t aware that the VerySpecialEpisode episodes were considered a parody by \\\'\\\'anyone\\\'\\\'. I frequent Television Without Pity, the official Glee forums, IMDB, the After Elton recaps, and whatever other recaps I can find, and the majority opinion is that they\\\'re playing the VerySpecialEpisode pretty straight. That part should at least be rewritten to say that there is some debate over whether it\\\'s a send up at all, because right now it just says \\\"Home\\\" is the only one that\\\'s even questionable.

I\\\'m sorry I was so hasty with the deletions, it just didn\\\'t seem like anyone was debating. 74.97.180.112 made good defense of theirs, but the other responses were just \\\"It\\\'s my opinion!\\\" and \\\"A lot of people feel that way.\\\" rather than a rebuttal or even acknowledgment of my concerns. A lot of these are reading like \\\"Episode 5 is a MAJOR deconstruction of bananas because there were bananas in it. Sometimes you make it into banana bread and sometimes you slip on the peel.\\\" It reminds me of the HowNotToWriteAnExample page: \\\"Deconstructed in Your Show: Your Show used this trope, but because it\\\'s Your Show, it\\\'s a deconstruction.\\\"

I have a problem with the \\\"My show is edgier and more subversive than YourShow!\\\" vibe on this page, especially when people break out the \\\'It\\\'s \\\'ironic\\\'\\\'.\\\" defense because, however unintentional, that reads like \\\"You\\\'re just too dumb to get it.\\\" It comes off as pretentious, especially since most of the attitude about everything this show is and is going to be was formed before the premiere of the second episode.

I actually wasn\\\'t aware that the VerySpecialEpisode parts were considered a parody by \\\'\\\'anyone\\\'\\\'. I frequent Television Without Pity, the official Glee forums, IMDB, the After Elton recaps, and whatever other recaps I can find, and the majority opinion is that they\\\'re playing the VerySpecialEpisode pretty straight. That part should at least be rewritten to say that there is some debate over whether it\\\'s a send up at all, because right now it just says \\\"Home\\\" is the only one that\\\'s even questionable.

I\\\'m sorry I was so hasty with the deletions, it just didn\\\'t seem like anyone was debating. 74.97.180.112 made good defense of theirs, but the other responses were just \\\"It\\\'s my opinion!\\\" and \\\"A lot of people feel that way.\\\" rather than a rebuttal or even acknowledgment of my concerns. A lot of these are reading like \\\"Episode 5 is a MAJOR deconstruction of bananas because there were bananas in it. Sometimes you make it into banana bread and sometimes you slip on the peel.\\\" It reminds me of the HowNotToWriteAnExample page: \\\"Deconstructed in Your Show: Your Show used this trope, but because it\\\'s Your Show, it\\\'s a deconstruction.\\\"

I have a problem with the \\\"My show is edgier and more subversive than YourShow!\\\" vibe on this page, especially when people break out the \\\'It\\\'s \\\'ironic\\\'\\\'.\\\" defense because, however unintentional, that reads like \\\"You\\\'re just too dumb to get it.\\\" It comes off as pretentious, especially since most of the attitude about everything this show is and is going to be was formed before the premiere of the second episode.

I actually wasn\\\'t aware that the VerySpecialEpisode parts were considered a parody by \\\'\\\'anyone\\\'\\\'. I frequent Television Without Pity, the official Glee forums, IMDB, the After Elton recaps, and whatever other recaps I can find, and the majority opinion is that they\\\'re playing the VerySpecialEpisode pretty straight. That part should at least be rewritten to say that there is some debate over whether it\\\'s a send up at all, because right now it just says \\\"Home\\\" is the only one that\\\'s even questionable. I don\\\'t even recall \\\"Home\\\" being that After-school special-esque.

I\\\'m sorry I was so hasty with the deletions, it just didn\\\'t seem like anyone was debating. 74.97.180.112 made good defense of theirs, but the other responses were just \\\"It\\\'s my opinion!\\\" and \\\"A lot of people feel that way.\\\" rather than a rebuttal of my arguments. A lot of these are reading like \\\"Episode 5 is a MAJOR deconstruction of bananas because there were bananas in it. Sometimes you make it into banana bread and sometimes you slip on the peel.\\\" It reminds me of the HowNotToWriteAnExample page: \\\"Deconstructed in Your Show: Your Show used this trope, but because it\\\'s Your Show, it\\\'s a deconstruction.\\\"

I have a problem with the \\\"My show is edgier and more subversive than YourShow!\\\" vibe on this page, especially when people break out the \\\'It\\\'s \\\'ironic\\\'\\\'.\\\" defense because, however unintentional, that reads like \\\"You\\\'re just too dumb to get it.\\\" It comes off as pretentious, especially since most of the attitude about everything this show is and is going to be was formed before the premiere of the second episode.

I actually wasn\\\'t aware that the VerySpecialEpisode parts were considered a parody by \\\'\\\'anyone\\\'\\\'. I frequent Television Without Pity, the official Glee forums, IMDB, the After Elton recaps, and whatever other recaps I can find, and the majority opinion is that they\\\'re playing the VerySpecialEpisode pretty straight. That part should at least be rewritten to say that there is some debate over whether it\\\'s a send up at all, because right now it just says \\\"Home\\\" is the only one that\\\'s even questionable. I don\\\'t even recall \\\"Home\\\" being that After-school special-esque.

I\\\'m sorry I was so hasty with the deletions, it just didn\\\'t seem like anyone was debating. 74.97.180.112 made good defense of theirs, but the other responses were just \\\"It\\\'s my opinion!\\\" and \\\"A lot of people feel that way.\\\" rather than a rebuttal of my arguments. A lot of these are reading like \\\"Episode 5 is a MAJOR deconstruction of bananas because there were bananas in it. Sometimes you make it into banana bread and sometimes you slip on the peel.\\\" It reminds me of the HowNotToWriteAnExample page: \\\"Deconstructed in Your Show: Your Show used this trope, but because it\\\'s Your Show, it\\\'s a deconstruction.\\\"

I have a problem with the \\\"My show is edgier and more subversive than YourShow!\\\" vibe on this page, especially when people break out the \\\'It\\\'s \\\'ironic\\\'\\\'.\\\" defense because, however unintentional, that reads like \\\"You\\\'re just too dumb to get it.\\\" It comes off as pretentious, especially since most of the attitude about everything this show is and is going to be was formed before the premiere of the second episode.

I actually wasn\\\'t aware that the VerySpecialEpisode parts were considered a parody by \\\'\\\'anyone\\\'\\\'. I frequent Television Without Pity, the official Glee forums, IMDB, the After Elton recaps, and whatever other recaps I can find, and the majority opinion is that they\\\'re playing the VerySpecialEpisode pretty straight. That part should at least be rewritten to say that there is some debate over whether it\\\'s a send up at all, because right now it just says \\\'\\\'Home\\\'\\\' is the only one that\\\'s even questionable.

I\\\'m sorry I was so hasty with the deletions, it just didn\\\'t seem like anyone was debating. 74.97.180.112 made good defense of theirs, but the other responses were just \\\"It\\\'s my opinion!\\\" and \\\"A lot of people feel that way.\\\" rather than a rebuttal of my arguments. A lot of these are reading like \\\"Episode 5 is a MAJOR deconstruction of bananas because there were bananas in it. Sometimes you make it into banana bread and sometimes you slip on the peel.\\\" It reminds me of the HowNotToWriteAnExample page: \\\"Deconstructed in Your Show: Your Show used this trope, but because it\\\'s Your Show, it\\\'s a deconstruction.\\\"

I have a problem with the \\\"My show is edgier and more subversive than YourShow!\\\" vibe on this page, especially when people break out the \\\'It\\\'s \\\'ironic\\\'\\\'.\\\" defense because, however unintentional, that reads like \\\"You\\\'re just too dumb to get it.\\\" It comes off as pretentious, especially since most of the attitude about everything this show is and is going to be was formed before the premiere of the second episode.

I actually wasn\\\'t aware that the VerySpecialEpisode parts were considered a parody by \\\'\\\'anyone\\\'\\\'. I frequent Television Without Pity, the official Glee forums, IMDB, the AfterElton recaps, and whatever other recaps I can find, and the majority opinion is that they\\\'re playing the VerySpecialEpisode pretty straight. That part should at least be rewritten to say that there is some debate over whether it\\\'s a send up at all, because right now it just says \\\'\\\'Home\\\'\\\' is the only one that\\\'s even questionable.