Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History YMMV / GameOfThrones

Go To

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Yes but we learn about most of Ramsay Bolton\'s atrocities in the books too, don\'t we? Mostly Theon. But that\'s because they are books, they write and tell, don\'t show. I believe we should wait until the whole arc [[spoiler:with Elia and the Red Viper]] comes up, then pUT him under the {{CompeteMonster}} list.
to:
Yes but we learn about most of Ramsay Bolton\\\'s atrocities in the books too, don\\\'t we? Mostly Theon. But that\\\'s because they are books, they write and tell, don\\\'t show. I believe we should wait until the whole arc [[spoiler:with Elia and the Red Viper]] comes up, then put him under the CM list.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Yes but we learn about most of Ramsay Bolton\'s atrocities in the books too, don\'t we? Mostly Theon. But that\'s because they are books, they write and tell, don\'t show. I believe we should wait until the whole arc [[spoiler:with Elia and the Red Viper]] comes up, then pUT him under the {{CompeteMonster CM}} list.
to:
Yes but we learn about most of Ramsay Bolton\\\'s atrocities in the books too, don\\\'t we? Mostly Theon. But that\\\'s because they are books, they write and tell, don\\\'t show. I believe we should wait until the whole arc [[spoiler:with Elia and the Red Viper]] comes up, then pUT him under the {{CompeteMonster}} list.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
My feeling about this episode is at least stuff keeps \'\'happening\'\'. The pacing of some others can be so slow. And if they\'d allowed the dilemma of leave-Spock-behind-or-threaten-whole-planet to be treated seriously, it could have been a compelling premise. (Perhaps more so if the aliens had just taken Spock\'s whole body, of course, and they didn\'t bring remote-controlled spock, who only ends up reminding us how useful robots would be to the crew.) Per \'\'IntoDarkness\'\' and maybe other works as well, you could also have Spock insisting on not being saved, for the sake of the civilization. The story could be a quest to find an alternative to the brain, or to make the planet self-sufficient (with more than just a speech). It could even have ended with some crew member volunteering to get de-brained -- hey, something similar happened at the end of \'\'Film/StarTrekTheMotionPicture\'\'. Ah well.
to:
My feeling about this episode is at least stuff keeps \\\'\\\'happening\\\'\\\'. The pacing of some others can be so slow. And if they\\\'d allowed the dilemma of leave-Spock-behind-or-threaten-whole-planet to be treated seriously, it could have been a compelling premise. (Perhaps more so if the aliens had just taken Spock\\\'s whole body, of course, and they didn\\\'t bring remote-controlled spock, who only ends up reminding us how useful robots would be to the crew.) Per \\\'\\\'Into Darkness\\\'\\\' and maybe other works as well, you could also have Spock insisting on not being saved, for the sake of the civilization. The story could be a quest to find an alternative to the brain, or to make the planet self-sufficient (with more than just a speech). It could even have ended with some crew member volunteering to get de-brained -- hey, something similar happened at the end of \\\'\\\'Film/StarTrekTheMotionPicture\\\'\\\'. Ah well.
Top