Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / AntiSue

Go To

[002] Oseng Current Version
Changed line(s) 13 from:
n
I\'m not going to go into a whole list of scenes where this crops up but the training scene with Erio and the manual is a prime example. Right off the top General Roland should have landed in a great deal of trouble when he took a weapon and opened fire on his fellow soldiers, who were involved in a training exercise that he was not. (Coincidentally, this kind of ambush/assault is one of the problems that shows up later – with some of Lyn\'s crew ambushing Signum) He thens make some general cliche comments about combat to the Forwards and Nanoha, and they act all surprised about this. He then goes on about a manual that he wrote full of apparently basic combat tactics – that the TSAB has apparently classified as special operations manual for Enforcers only. Overall Chapter Eight is the worst overall chapter in the entire fan fic, and the worst offender in making the TSAB seem incompetent. I doubt that was the author\'s intention though.
to:
I\\\'m not going to go into a whole list of scenes where this crops up but the training scene with Erio and the manual is a prime example. Right off the top General Roland should have landed in a great deal of trouble when he took a weapon and opened fire on his fellow soldiers, who were involved in a training exercise that he was not. (Coincidentally, this kind of ambush/assault is one of the problems that shows up later – with some of Lyn\\\'s crew ambushing Signum and Vita, who were observing a training operation) He then makes some general cliche comments about combat to the Forwards and Nanoha, and they act all surprised about this. He then goes on about a manual that he wrote full of apparently basic combat tactics – that the TSAB has apparently classified as special operations manual for Enforcers only. Overall Chapter Eight is the worst overall chapter in the entire fan fic, and the worst offender in making the TSAB seem incompetent. I doubt that was the author\\\'s intention though.
Changed line(s) 19 from:
n
Personally I hope that Admiral Tigerclaw decides to continue the story and I would recommend it, with the caveat that there are issues and areas that need some work and/or a objective second look.
to:
Personally I hope that Admiral Tigerclaw decides to continue the story and I would recommend it, with the caveat that there are issues and areas that need some work and/or a objective second look.

Edited for some grammar issues - Oseng
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
I don\'t find the technology vs magical technology to be all that jarring though I do think that Tigerclaw does, at times, underestimate the TSAB\'s tech. The only time where the mage\'s barrier jackets and other defenses seem weak to me is the scene with Hayate at the power plant. And that can be chalked up to A) they operating inside a fairly powerful AMF, and B) Hayate is not quite a combat mage like Nanoha or Fate – instead it seems that she has concentrated on climbing the ranks etc.
to:
I don\\\'t find the technology vs magical technology to be all that jarring though I do think that Tigerclaw does, at times, underestimate the TSAB\\\'s tech. The only time where the mage\\\'s barrier jackets and other defenses seem weak to me is the scene with Hayate at the power plant. And that can be chalked up to A) they operating inside a fairly powerful AMF, and B) Hayate is not quite a combat mage like Nanoha or Fate – instead it seems that she has concentrated on climbing the ranks etc. She is after all pretty much canonically a glass cannon.
Top