Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / Eagleland

Go To

[002] OJtheLION Current Version
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
*I\'m aware of how the endings are a mash-up, but to me it always seemed more like HF\'s ending with other characters added in than the other ones, probably because Sakura\'s already living in the Emiya house and Rider isn\'t even close to being a possible resident in any other ending. I hadn\'t heard the Normal End possibility yet, but that\'s certainly an interesting take on it, although from what I can gather [[spoiler: Shirou is alive and well after the ending, when Avenger goes back to the void]]. I think saying Saber wouldn\'t matter that much compared to Sakura is a bit unfair since Shirou does some positively suicidal things to try to save Saber in all three routes, at least if you include bad/dead ends as possible in-character decisions. Even when she\'s not the main love interest, she clearly becomes really important to Shirou no matter which route you take. As far as her being saveable, remember that Nasu completely makes up these rules. That Rule Breaker wasn\'t a solution of first resort for the big problem of HF always seemed to me like bending the rules to make more drama. That\'s understandable though, Rule Breaker would kind of be a StoryBreakerSuperpower if so.
to:
*I\\\'m aware of how the endings are a mash-up, but to me it always seemed more like HF\\\'s ending with other characters added in than the other ones, probably because Sakura\\\'s already living in the Emiya house and Rider isn\\\'t even close to being a possible resident in any other ending. I hadn\\\'t heard the Normal End possibility yet, but that\\\'s certainly an interesting take on it, although from what I can gather [[spoiler: Shirou is alive and well after the ending, when Avenger goes back to the void]]. I think saying Saber wouldn\\\'t matter that much compared to Sakura is a bit unfair since Shirou does some positively suicidal things to try to save Saber in all three routes, at least if you include bad/dead ends as possible in-character decisions. Even when she\\\'s not the main love interest, she clearly becomes really important to Shirou no matter which route you take. As far as her being saveable, remember that Nasu completely makes up these rules. That Rule Breaker wasn\\\'t a solution of first resort for the big problem of HF always seemed to me like bending the rules to make more drama. That\\\'s understandable though, Rule Breaker would kind of be a StoryBreakerPower if so.
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
*I \'\'hope\'\' the mangaka at least realizes he\'s altering the backstory, which I\'m sure he does, although it may not appear that way at times. It\'s a bit late to make a new season of FSN for the Heaven\'s Feel route, but hopefully the next Type-Moon VN\'s anime adaptation will do something like I mentioned if it has the same RoadCones format (I haven\'t read Mahoutsukai no Yoru, but I assume they\'ll make the VN like that).
to:
*I \\\'\\\'hope\\\'\\\' the mangaka at least realizes he\\\'s altering the backstory, which I\\\'m sure he does, although it may not appear that way at times. It\\\'s a bit late to make a new season of FSN for the Heaven\\\'s Feel route, but hopefully the next Type-Moon VN\\\'s anime adaptation will do something like I mentioned if it has the same RoadCone format (I haven\\\'t read Mahoutsukai no Yoru, but I assume they\\\'ll make the VN like that).
Top