Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Series / Bones

Go To

[006] wombat18 Current Version
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
Current entry: You Fail Physics Forever: As an anthropologist Bones should know that any solid has a melting point, if it doesn\'t decompose or goes straight to gas for. But according to her, bones cannot melt. Despite the episode with the corpse is just that: completely melted.
to:
Current entry: You Fail Physics Forever: As an anthropologist Bones should know that any solid has a melting point, if it doesn\\\'t decompose or goes straight to gas for. But according to her, bones cannot melt. Despite the episode with the corpse is just that: completely melted.

Any opinions from those slightly more grounded in physics than I am?
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
The entry under \'You fail physics forever\' makes little sense. It\'s incoherent and does not clearly reference the episode in question (the Twisted Bones in the Melted Truck.) There is, however, a perfectly good alternative YFPF in this episode which is that the magnesium fire which \'melted\' the bones would have been more than hot enough to melt the bullet that was found intact in the skeleton.
to:
The entry under \\\'You fail physics forever\\\' is incoherent and does not clearly reference the episode in question (the Twisted Bones in the Melted Truck.) In this episode a scientific explanation is given for the melted bones. It is not really a failure on Brennan\\\'s part that she could not have predicted the behaviour of bones under the very obscure circumstances which arose in the episode, especially since she is an anthropologist and not a chemist or a physicist.
Changed line(s) 2 from:
to:
There is, however, a perfectly good alternative YFPF in this episode which is that the magnesium fire which \\\'melted\\\' the bones would have been more than hot enough to melt the bullet that was found intact in the skeleton.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
The entry under \'You fail physics forever\' makes little or no sense. Solids can melt, or they can burn, or they can sublimate straight from solid to gas. Whoever submitted this has obviously not tried to melt e.g paper recently. On top of that it\'s incoherent and does not clearly reference the episode in question (the Twisted Bones in the Melted Truck.) There is, however, a perfectly good alternative YFPF in this episode which is that the magnesium fire which supposedly \'melted\' the bones would have been more than hot enough to melt the bullet that was found intact in the skeleton.
to:
The entry under \\\'You fail physics forever\\\' makes little sense. It\\\'s incoherent and does not clearly reference the episode in question (the Twisted Bones in the Melted Truck.) There is, however, a perfectly good alternative YFPF in this episode which is that the magnesium fire which \\\'melted\\\' the bones would have been more than hot enough to melt the bullet that was found intact in the skeleton.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
The entry under \'You fail physics forever\' makes little or no sense. Solids can melt, or they can burn, or they can sublimate straight from solid to gas. Whoever submitted this has obviously not tried to melt e.g paper recently. On top of that it\'s incoherent. Suggest removing this completely.
to:
The entry under \\\'You fail physics forever\\\' makes little or no sense. Solids can melt, or they can burn, or they can sublimate straight from solid to gas. Whoever submitted this has obviously not tried to melt e.g paper recently. On top of that it\\\'s incoherent and does not clearly reference the episode in question (the Twisted Bones in the Melted Truck.) There is, however, a perfectly good alternative YFPF in this episode which is that the magnesium fire which supposedly \\\'melted\\\' the bones would have been more than hot enough to melt the bullet that was found intact in the skeleton.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
The entry under \'You fail physics forever\' makes little or no sense. Solids can melt, or they can burn, or they can sublimate straight from solid to gas. Whoever submitted this has obviously not tried to melt e.g paper recently. Suggest removing this completely.
to:
The entry under \\\'You fail physics forever\\\' makes little or no sense. Solids can melt, or they can burn, or they can sublimate straight from solid to gas. Whoever submitted this has obviously not tried to melt e.g paper recently. On top of that it\\\'s incoherent. Suggest removing this completely.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
The entry under \'You fail physics forever\' makes little or no sense. Solids can melt, or they can burn, or they can sublimate straight from solid to gas. Whoever submitted this has obviously not tried to melt e.g paper recently. Suggest removing this completely.
to:
The entry under \\\'You fail physics forever\\\' makes little or no sense. Solids can melt, or they can burn, or they can sublimate straight from solid to gas. Whoever submitted this has obviously not tried to melt e.g paper recently. Suggest removing this completely.

Current entry: You Fail Physics Forever: As an anthropologist Bones should know that any solid has a melting point, if it doesn\\\'t decompose or goes straight to gas for. But according to her, bones cannot melt. Despite the episode with the corpse is just that: completely melted.
Top