Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / AuthorAppeal

Go To

[004] Wyldchyld Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
That\'s not what AST is. AST is for when a creator actively does something in response to a fandom\'s attitude, and the fandom thinks it\'s done the job of \
to:
That\\\'s not what AST is. AST is for when a creator actively does something in response to a fandom\\\'s attitude, and the fandom thinks it\\\'s done the job of \\\"fixing\\\" the issue they had.

This situation is one troper edit warring an entry because they personally feel the heroes are to blame for Ironwood snapping when the entry they\\\'re edit-warring has nothing to do with Ironwood in the first place (it\\\'s about the heroes reconciling with Ozpin because they now feel that they understand why he was keeping secrets from them -- that\\\'s got nothing to do with how they interact with, or feel about, Ironwood\\\'s situation). It also has nothing to do with the fandom\\\'s feelings about how the heroes treated Ozpin because Volume 8 was being written as Volume 7 was airing, and the heroes just reach a natural conclusion based on how both Volumes 7-8 unfolded in-universe. There\\\'s no claim here that the authors were trying to fix a fandom complaint about Volume 6, it\\\'s just a case of fans feeling better now they\\\'ve seen how that plot thread concluded.

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
That\'s not what AST is. AST is for when a creator actively does something in response to a fandom\'s attitude, and the fandom thinks it\'s done the job of \
to:
That\\\'s not what AST is. AST is for when a creator actively does something in response to a fandom\\\'s attitude, and the fandom thinks it\\\'s done the job of \\\"fixing\\\" the issue they had.

This situation is one troper edit warring an entry because they personally feel the heroes are to blame for Ironwood snapping when the entry they\\\'re edit-warring has nothing to do with Ironwood in the first place (it\\\'s about the heroes reconciling with Ozpin because they now feel that they understand why he was keeping secrets from them -- that\\\'s got nothing to do with how they interact with, or feel about, Ironwood\\\'s situation). It also has nothing to do with the fandom\\\'s feelings about how the heroes treated Ozpin because Volume 8 was being written as Volume 7 was airing, and the heroes just reach a natural conclusion based on how both Volumes 7-8 unfolded in-universe. There\\\'s no claim here that the authors were trying to fix a fandom complaint, it\\\'s just \\\"plot unfolds, character development happens, fans appreciate the outcome\\\".



Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
That\'s not what AST is. AST is for when a creator actively does something in response to a fandom\'s attitude, and the fandom thinks it\'s done the job of \
to:
That\\\'s not what AST is. AST is for when a creator actively does something in response to a fandom\\\'s attitude, and the fandom thinks it\\\'s done the job of \\\"fixing\\\" the issue they had.

This situation is one troper edit warring an entry because they personally feel the heroes are to blame for Ironwood snapping when the entry they\\\'re edit-warring has nothing to do with Ironwood in the first place (it\\\'s about the heroes reconciling with Ozpin because they now feel that they understand why he was keeping secrets from them -- that\\\'s got nothing to do with how they interact with, or feel about, Ironwood\\\'s situation). It also has nothing to do with the fandom\\\'s feelings about how the heroes treated Ozpin because Volume 8 was being written as Volume 7 was airing, and the heroes just reach a natural conclusion based on how both Volumes 7-8 unfolded in-universe. There\\\'s no claim here that the authors were trying to fix a fandom complaint, it\\\'s just \\\"plot unfolds, character development happens\\\".



Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
That\'s not what AST is. AST is for when a creator actively does something in response to a fandom\'s attitude, and the fandom thinks it\'s done the job of \
to:
That\\\'s not what AST is. AST is for when a creator actively does something in response to a fandom\\\'s attitude, and the fandom thinks it\\\'s done the job of \\\"fixing\\\" the issue they had.

This situation is one troper edit warring an entry because they personally feel the heroes are to blame for Ironwood snapping when the entry they\\\'re edit-warring has nothing to do with Ironwood in the first place (it\\\'s about the heroes reconciling with Ozpin because they now feel that they understand why he was keeping secrets from them -- that\\\'s got nothing to do with how they interact with, or feel about, Ironwood\\\'s situation).

Top