Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / PublicDomainStories

Go To

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
What \
to:
What \\\"marked spoiler folder\\\"? The folder in the character page is named \\\"Shiraori\\\". That makes no sense.

What you said was: \\\"you don\\\'t even know that name until you know who she is, so you can\\\'t connect it to the person that killed Julius\\\" which is false. Anyone who has seen up to the point that Julius gets killed and then scrolls down the page and sees Shiraori is going to see the picture of the woman that killed Julius, along with a warning that she is a WalkingSpoiler and to click on the link for more info at their own risk. Again, the argument is flat out invalid.

If, instead, you are arguing \\\"people who see the folder but don\\\'t open it won\\\'t know who Shiraori is\\\", then....\\\'\\\'good\\\'\\\'. That\\\'s exactly what we want. If they don\\\'t open the folder and don\\\'t know who Shiraori is, then that is the best case scenario for them not being spoiled.

As it stands, if no one else comments after us, then no further action can be taken on the page. It will literally stand as it is now, because that was the last thing we all agreed on, except for yourself.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
What \
to:
What \\\"marked spoiler folder\\\"? The folder in the character page is named \\\"Shiraori\\\". That makes no sense.

What you said was: \\\"you don\\\'t even know that name until you know who she is, so you can\\\'t connect it to the person that killed Julius\\\" which is false. Anyone who has seen up to the point that Julius gets killed and then scrolls down the page and sees Shiraori is going to see the picture of the woman that killed Julius, along with a warning that she is a WalkingSpoiler and to click on the link for more info at their own risk. Again, the argument is flat out invalid.

As it stands, if no one else comments after us, then no further action can be taken on the page. It will literally stand as it is now, because that was the last thing we all agreed on, except for yourself.
Top