Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / AdventureGuild

Go To

[003] SensuBean Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Well, all right, although some of the bashing types have gone so extremely overboard in comparison that they really do read this way to me, but I\'ll try to cut it down later when I have time again unless you feel like it. I\'m not sure what else to write though, and it really did read as extremely slanted in the other direction for Ryoga. I don\'t think that it was a problem to include the BaseBreaker different alignment interpretations though. About \
to:
Well, all right, although some of the bashing types have gone so extremely overboard in comparison that they really do read this way to me, but I\\\'ll try to cut it down later when I have time again unless you feel like it. I\\\'m not sure what else to write though, and it really did read as extremely slanted in the other direction for Ryoga. I don\\\'t think that it was a problem to include the BaseBreaker different alignment interpretations though. About \\\"excusing\\\", I don\\\'t consciously do that. I really do read the characters like this, (and for what it\\\'s worth Rowan Seven did think that I write a \\\"wonderful\\\" Akane, possibly because her frantic obsessive drive and cyclical shifts make much more sense for someone who is bipolar himself or herself, even though she\\\'s a comical exaggeration) but of course that doesn\\\'t mean that I\\\'m right about everything either. We can probably reach a gradual mutually beneficial compromise through contributing different details though, and the next time I\\\'ll write when I haven\\\'t just read some obnoxiously extremist story.

Regarding the Mousse fight, and compared to everything else regularly going on, I don\\\'t see the problem at all. Ranma had the opportunity to get rid of a great trouble source, did not have some major moral breakdown about this, simply a mild dislike, has done much worse things than throwing a fight so someonne could look good to a prospective girlfriend elsewhere (if it had been a humiliating thing before an audience as with the apology-glasses it would have been different), and he asked Mousse to decide for himself during the fight, although it has turned a bit fuzzy so maybe I should reread the exact exchange between Akane and him before that. Simply mentioning it is simply a legitimate point. However, there are other instances when the Tendos actually have been jerks about it, such as putting multiple cats on him right after they learned about the phobia. Kasumi at least apparently simply didn\\\'t get that anyone could be afraid of a cute kitten, but the rest, well I suppose disbeliief factors in, but yeah, mostly just plain jerkhood. That could be mentioned.

I couldn\\\'t find any knife-threatening in the Nodoka cooking lessons chapter when I checked it a while back.

As for Ryoga\\\'s biggest \\\"no seriously mitigating circumstances such as Ranma trying to kill him and Akane if they didn\\\'t have gay sex regularly\\\", that\\\'s provbably right at the beginning when Shampoo hunts Ranma. I seem to remember that he tried to splash Ranma just to be a jerk or somesuch.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Well, all right, although some of the bashing types have gone so extremely overboard in comparison that they really do read this way to me, but I\'ll try to cut it down later when I have time again unless you feel like it. I\'m not sure what else to write though, and it really did read as extremely slanted in the other direction for Ryoga. I don\'t think that it was a problem to include the BaseBreaker different alignment interpretations though. About \
to:
Well, all right, although some of the bashing types have gone so extremely overboard in comparison that they really do read this way to me, but I\\\'ll try to cut it down later when I have time again unless you feel like it. I\\\'m not sure what else to write though, and it really did read as extremely slanted in the other direction for Ryoga. I don\\\'t think that it was a problem to include the BaseBreaker different alignment interpretations though. About \\\"excusing\\\", I don\\\'t consciously do that. I really do read the characters like this, (and for what it\\\'s worth RowanSeven did at think that I write a \\\"wonderful Akane\\\", possibly because her frantic obsessive drive and cyclical shifts make much more sense for someone who is bipolar himself or herself, even though she\\\'s a comical exaggeration) but of course that doesn\\\'t mean that I\\\'m right about everything either. We can probably reach a gradual compromise with filling in details though, and the next time I\\\'ll write when I haven\\\'t just read some obnoxiously extremist story.

Regarding the Mousse fight, and compared to everything else regularly going on, I don\\\'t see the problem at all. Ranma had the opportunity to get rid of a great trouble source, did not have some major moral breakdown about this, simply a mild dislike, has done much worse things than throwing a fight so someonne could look good to a prospective girlfriend elsewhere (if it had been a humiliating thing before an audience as with the apology-glasses it would have been different), and he asked Mousse to decide for himself during the fight, although it has turned a bit fuzzy so maybe I should reread the exact exchange between Akane and him before that. Simply mentioning it is simply a legitimate point. However, there are other instances when the Tendos actually have been jerks about it, such as putting multiple cats on him right after they learned about the phobia. Kasumi at least apparently simply didn\\\'t get that anyone could be afraid of a cute kitten, but the rest, well I suppose disbeliief factors in, but yeah, mostly just plain jerkhood. That could be mentioned.

I couldn\\\'t find any knife-threatening in the Nodoka cooking lessons chapter when I checked it a while back.

As for Ryoga\\\'s biggest \\\"no seriously mitigating circumstances such as Ranma trying to kill him and Akane if they didn\\\'t have gay sex regularly\\\", that\\\'s provbably right at the beginning when Shampoo hunts Ranma. I seem to remember that he tried to splash Ranma just to be a jerk or somesuch.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Well, all right, although some of the bashing types have gone so extremely overboard in comparison that they really do read this way to me, but I\'ll try to cut it down later when I have time again unless you feel like it. I\'m not sure what else to write though, and it really did read as extremely slanted in the other direction for Ryoga. I don\'t think that it was a problem to include the BaseBreaker different alignment interpretations though.
to:
Well, all right, although some of the bashing types have gone so extremely overboard in comparison that they really do read this way to me, but I\\\'ll try to cut it down later when I have time again unless you feel like it. I\\\'m not sure what else to write though, and it really did read as extremely slanted in the other direction for Ryoga. I don\\\'t think that it was a problem to include the BaseBreaker different alignment interpretations though. About \\\"excusing\\\", I don\\\'t consciously do that. I really do read the characters like this, (and for what it\\\'s worth RowanSeven did at think that I write a \\\"wonderful Akane\\\", possibly because her frantic obsessive drive and cyclical shifts make much more sense for someone who is bipolar himself or herself, even though she\\\'s a comical exaggeration) but of course that doesn\\\'t mean that I\\\'m right about everything either. We can probably reach a gradual compromise with filling in details though, and the next time I\\\'ll write when I haven\\\'t just read some obnoxiously extremist story.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
As for Ryoga\'s biggest \
to:
As for Ryoga\\\'s biggest \\\"no seriously mitigating circumstances such as \\\"Ranma trying to kill him if they didn\\\'t have gay sex regularly\\\", that\\\'s provbably right at thr beginning when Shampoo hunts Ranma. I seem to remember that he tried to splash Ranma just to be a jerk or somesuch.
Top