[005]
Nightsky
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I love it too, but \'\'All-Time Great doesn\'t equal Episode I Really Liked.\'\' I love \
to:
I love it too, but \\\'\\\'All-Time Great doesn\\\'t equal Episode I Really Liked.\\\'\\\' I love \\\"Enlightenment\\\" and \\\"The Visitation\\\", too, but that doesn\\\'t mean I think they belong on the list of truly great greats.
Put another way: GallifreyBase runs a survey ranking the serials. The top five were: 1. Talons of Weng-Chiang; 2. Empty Child/ Doctor Dances; 3. Caves of Androzani; 4. Robots of Death; 5. Blink. Nor did any of those finish outside the top ten last year.
\\\"The Eleventh Hour\\\", as much as you and I loved it, doesn\\\'t seem poised to join them. It scored an 8.37 / 10 average on Gallifrey Base; if ranked in the same survey I mentioned above (which was released before the season 31 began), it\\\'d have placed 25th (out of about 200): a solid performer, certainly well above average, but not in the creme de la creme.
Give it time. Consensus will emerge, and once it does, it\\\'s pretty stable.
Put another way: GallifreyBase runs a survey ranking the serials. The top five were: 1. Talons of Weng-Chiang; 2. Empty Child/ Doctor Dances; 3. Caves of Androzani; 4. Robots of Death; 5. Blink. Nor did any of those finish outside the top ten last year.
\\\"The Eleventh Hour\\\", as much as you and I loved it, doesn\\\'t seem poised to join them. It scored an 8.37 / 10 average on Gallifrey Base; if ranked in the same survey I mentioned above (which was released before the season 31 began), it\\\'d have placed 25th (out of about 200): a solid performer, certainly well above average, but not in the creme de la creme.
Give it time. Consensus will emerge, and once it does, it\\\'s pretty stable.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I love it too, but \'\'All-Time Great doesn\'t equal Episode I Really Liked.\'\' The ones on the list weren\'t added because someone loved them; they were added because they had genuinely emerged as consensus favorites over the fandom\'s 45-year history.
to:
I love it too, but \\\'\\\'All-Time Great doesn\\\'t equal Episode I Really Liked.\\\'\\\' I love \\\"Enlightenment\\\" and \\\"The Visitation\\\", too, but that doesn\\\'t mean I think they belong on the list of truly great greats.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
\
to:
\\\"The Eleventh Hour\\\", as much as you and I loved it, doesn\\\'t seem poised to join them. It scored an 8.37 / 10 average on Gallifrey Base; if ranked in the same survey I mentioned above (which was released before the season 31 began), it\\\'d have placed 25th (out of about 200): a solid performer, certainly well above average, but not in the creme de la creme.
Give it time. Consensus will emerge, and once it does, it\\\'s pretty stable.
Give it time. Consensus will emerge, and once it does, it\\\'s pretty stable.