[002]
Clanger00
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
The issue is that whilst the portrayals of these societies/groups is exaggerated, the \'corrections\' of these people is not an exaggeration, they\'re highly likely to be Lind\'s own beliefs. The idea that black people are committing genocide against whites in Atlanta is an exaggeration, but the idea that racial segregation is a good thing is not an exaggeration. The idea that feminists have starting cloning themselves is an exaggeration, but the idea that feminist women need to get back in their husband\'s home is not an exaggeration. Some of the book is the author Strawmanning his opponents, and some of the book is the author genuinely presenting his political views (like the idea that public hangings will cause crime to fall). But yes, since the book is such a mess of genuine opinions and caricatures then we can remove the part about pushing political opinions.
to:
The issue is that whilst the portrayals of these societies/groups is exaggerated, the \\\'corrections\\\' of these people is not an exaggeration, they\\\'re highly likely to be Lind\\\'s own beliefs. The idea that black people are committing genocide against whites in Atlanta is an exaggeration, but the idea that racial segregation is a good thing is not an exaggeration. The idea that feminists have starting cloning themselves is an exaggeration, but the idea that feminist women need to get back in their husband\\\'s home is not an exaggeration. Some of the book is the author Strawmanning his opponents, and some of the book is the author genuinely presenting his political views (like the idea that public hangings will cause crime to fall). But yes, since the book is such a mess of genuine opinions and caricatures then we can remove all parts about any political opinions the author may have.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
Agree on the paleoconservative change, since libertarian is a much vaguer term.
to:
Agree on the paleoconservative change, since libertarian is a much vaguer term. Also \\\'\\\'all\\\'\\\' of your claims are unsourced, so your (unsourced) claim that he\\\'s a libertarian is
worth just as much as the (unsourced) claim that he isn\\\'t a libertarian.
worth just as much as the (unsourced) claim that he isn\\\'t a libertarian.
