Discussion History Manga / WanderingSon

I hate it when people call characterization in this story \\\"historical\\\" because it\\\'s NOT. It\\\'s just the authors arbitrarily assigning personalities to the characters. Maybe they\\\'re based on the authors\\\' ideas of history and historical events but that can never be regarded as any kind of historical WordOfGod. It\\\'s utterly subjective and open to biases, in some cases it\\\'s very much flawed (see the edit on Prussia, but there are other examples), and knowing the authors\\\' opinions on certain issues some of them have very disturbing implications.

This is not an APH fic. It\\\'s a well-written (from a technical standpoint) piece of original fiction inspired by APH. It has an original plot and characterization that probably appeals to those who like this very DarkerAndEdgier sort of writing, and which others may have issues with, especially when they try to find traces of APH characters in it. But it\\\'s not an APH fic. Not because it\\\'s serious and lacks fun and giggles (there are some great serious, history-inspired APH fics out there), but because it has no APH characters. AU is no excuse for this level of OutOfCharacter and CanonDefilement.

I hate it when people call characterization in this story \\\"historical\\\" because it\\\'s NOT. It\\\'s just the authors arbitrarily assigning personalities to the characters. Maybe they\\\'re based on the authors\\\' ideas of history and historical events but that can never be regarded as any kind of historical WordOfGod. It\\\'s utterly subjective and open to biases, in some cases it\\\'s very much flawed (see the edit on Prussia, but there are other examples), and knowing the authors\\\' opinions on certain issues some of them have very disturbing implications.

This is not an APH fic. It\\\'s a well-written (from a technical standpoint) piece of original fiction inspired by APH. It has an original plot and characterization that probably appeals to those who like this very DarkerAndEdgier sort of writing, and which others may have issues with, especially when they try to find traces of APH characters in it. But it has nothing in common with APH, not because it lacks fun and giggles (there are some great serious, history-inspired APH fics out there), but because it has no APH characters. AU is no excuse for this level of OutOfCharacter and CanonDefilement.

I hate it when people call characterization in this story \\\"historical\\\" because it\\\'s NOT. It\\\'s just the authors arbitrarily assigning personalities to the characters. Maybe they\\\'re based on the authors\\\' ideas of history and historical events but that can never be regarded as any kind of historical WordOfGod. It\\\'s utterly subjective and open to biases, in some cases it\\\'s very much flawed (see the edit on Prussia, but there are other examples), and knowing the authors\\\' opinions on certain issues some of them have very disturbing implications.

This is not an APH fic. It\\\'s a well-written (from a technical standpoint) piece of original fiction inspired by APH. It has an original plot and characterization that probably appeals to those who like this very DarkerAndEdgier sort of writing, and which others may have issues with. But it has nothing in common with APH, not because it lacks fun and giggles (there are some great serious, history-inspired APH fics out there), but because it has no APH characters. AU is no excuse for this level of OutOfCharacter and CanonDefilement.

I hate it when people call characterization in this story \\\"historical\\\" because it\\\'s NOT. It\\\'s just the authors arbitrarily assigning personalities to the characters. Maybe they\\\'re based on the authors\\\' ideas of history and historical events but that can never be regarded as any kind of historical WordOfGod. It\\\'s utterly subjective and open to biases, in some cases it\\\'s very much flawed (see the edit on Prussia, but there are other examples), and knowing the authors\\\' opinions on certain issues some of them have very disturbing implications.

This is not an APH fic. It\\\'s a well-written (from a technical standpoint) piece of original fiction inspired by APH. It has an original plot and characterization that probably appeals to those who like this very DarkerAndEdgier sort of writing, and which others may have issues with. But it has nothing in common with APH, not because it lacks fun and giggles but because it has no APH characters. AU is not an excuse for this level of CharacterDerailment.

I hate it when people call characterization in this story \\\"historical\\\" because it\\\'s NOT. It\\\'s just the authors arbitrarily assigning personalities to the characters. Maybe they\\\'re based on the authors\\\' ideas of history and historical events but that can never be regarded as any kind of historical WordOfGod. It\\\'s utterly subjective and open to biases, in some cases it\\\'s very much flawed (see the edit on Prussia, but there are other examples), and knowing the authors\\\' opinions on certain issues some of them have very disturbing implications.

This is not an APH fic. It\\\'s a well-written (from a technical standpoint) piece of original fiction inspired by APH. It has an original plot and characterization that probably appeals to those who like this very DarkerAndEdgier sort of writing, and which others may have issues with. But it has nothing in common with APH, not because it lacks fun and giggles, it\\\'s because it has no APH characters. AU is not an excuse for this level of CharacterDerailment.