Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / KnightsAndKnaves

Go To

[009] ritzoreo Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
How does Batman figure out that Ray didn't kill Sue Dibny? We see how the lab researches discover the diminute footprints that point to the Atom, but when Jean and Ray Palmer are discussing Dibny's death there's a cut to Bats saying
to:
How does Ba
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
How does Batman figure out that Ray didn't kill Sue Dibny? We see how the lab researches discover the diminute footprints that point to the Atom, but when Jean and Ray Palmer are discussing Dibny's death there's a cut to Bats saying
to:
How does Batman figure out that Ray didn\'t kill Sue Dibny? We see how the lab researches discover the diminute footprints that point to the Atom, but when Jean and Ray Palmer are discussing Dibny\'s death there\'s a cut to Bats saying \"Ray? It\'s not Ray...\" seemingly deducing the answer just by looking at photos of Sue. It\'s implied that Batman knew it was Jean because he\'s trying to find Ray anyhow. Is it ever explained how he deduced Ray was not the killer?
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
There are four scenarios if asked the question as
to:
There are four scenarios if asked the question as \"If I asked you if the door you\'re guarding leads to where I want to go, would you say \'yes\'?\" to a single guard

*If the lying guard is guarding the correct door, he would have to say he is guarding the correct door since it is the opposite of the answer he would give if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
*If the lying guard is guarding the wrong door, he would have to say he is guarding the wrong door since it is the opposite of the answer he would give if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
* If the truthful guard is guarding the correct door, he would say he is guarding the correct door because that is truthfully what he would say if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
* If the truthful guard is guarding the wrong door, he would say he is guarding the wrong door because that is truthfully what he would say if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
There are four scenarios stated if asked the question as
to:
There are four scenarios if asked the question as \"If I asked you if the door you\'re guarding leads to where I want to go, would you say \'yes\'?\"

*If the lying guard is guarding the correct door, he would have to say he is guarding the correct door since it is the opposite of the answer he would give if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
*If the lying guard is guarding the wrong door, he would have to say he is guarding the wrong door since it is the opposite of the answer he would give if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
* If the truthful guard is guarding the correct door, he would say he is guarding the correct door because that is truthfully what he would say if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
* If the truthful guard is guarding the wrong door, he would say he is guarding the wrong door because that is truthfully what he would say if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
There are four scenarios stated
to:
There are four scenarios stated if asked the question as \"If I asked you if the door you\'re guarding leads to where I want to go, would you say \'yes\'?\"

*If the lying guard is guarding the correct door, he would have to say he is guarding the correct door since it is the opposite of the answer he would give if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
*If the lying guard is guarding the wrong door, he would have to say he is guarding the wrong door since it is the opposite of the answer he would give if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
* If the truthful guard is guarding the correct door, he would say he is guarding the correct door because that is truthfully what he would say if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
* If the truthful guard is guarding the wrong door, he would say he is guarding the wrong door because that is truthfully what he would say if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
There are four scenarios stated
to:
There are four scenarios stated \"If I asked you if the door you\'re guarding leads to where I want to go, would you say \'yes\'?\"

*If the lying guard is guarding the correct door, he would have to say he is guarding the correct door since it is the opposite of the answer he would give if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
*If the lying guard is guarding the wrong door, he would have to say he is guarding the wrong door since it is the opposite of the answer he would give if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
* If the truthful guard is guarding the correct door, he would say he is guarding the correct door because that is truthfully what he would say if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
* If the truthful guard is guarding the wrong door, he would say he is guarding the wrong door because that is truthfully what he would say if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Examples
to:
There are four scenarios stated \"If I asked you if the door you\'re guarding leads to where I want to go, would you say \'yes\'?\"
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
*If the lying guard is guarding the correct door, he would have to say he guarding the correct door since it is the opposite of the answer he would give if you asked him the simple question
*If the lying guard is guarding the wrong door, he would have to say he guarding the wrong door since it is the opposite of the answer he would give if you asked him the simple question
* If the truthful guard is guarding the correct door, he would say he guarding the correct door because that is truthfully what he would say if you asked him the simple question
* If the truthful guard is guarding the wrong door, he would say he guarding the wrong door because that is truthfully what he would say if you asked him the simple question
to:
*If the lying guard is guarding the correct door, he would have to say he guarding the correct door since it is the opposite of the answer he would give if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
*If the lying guard is guarding the wrong door, he would have to say he guarding the wrong door since it is the opposite of the answer he would give if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
* If the truthful guard is guarding the correct door, he would say he guarding the correct door because that is truthfully what he would say if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
* If the truthful guard is guarding the wrong door, he would say he guarding the wrong door because that is truthfully what he would say if you asked him \"does the door lead where I want\"
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
*If the lying guard is guarding the correct door, he would have to say he guarding the correct door since it is the opposite of the answer the simple question he would give if you asked him the simple question
to:
*If the lying guard is guarding the correct door, he would have to say he guarding the correct door since it is the opposite of the answer he would give if you asked him the simple question
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
*If the lying guard is guarding the correct door, he would have to say he guarding the correct door since it is the opposite of the answer the simple question
*If the lying guard is guarding the wrong door, he would have to say he guarding the wrong door since it is the opposite of the answer the simple question
to:
*If the lying guard is guarding the correct door, he would have to say he guarding the correct door since it is the opposite of the answer the simple question he would give if you asked him the simple question
*If the lying guard is guarding the wrong door, he would have to say he guarding the wrong door since it is the opposite of the answer he would give if you asked him the simple question
Top