PageAction:
StarWarsACI
16th Apr '20 9:57:39 AM
Crown Description:
Sandbox.Star Wars ACI has collected examples of Alternative Character Interpretation for Star Wars characters across more than 20 pages, including AlternativeCharacterInterpretation.Star Wars. Some characters have entries on AlternativeCharacterInterpretation.Star Wars, plus the YMMV pages for works where they make appearances, ex. Anakin Skywalker is on franchise-wide, Return of the Jedi, each of the prequel films, Thrawn: Alliances, plus the Darth Vader entries. This is just looking at the canon namespaces and not Legends. Before fixing issues with the examples themselves, we need to decide on how this trope will be organized for this franchise. These options are mutually exclusive; while you can find more than one acceptable, we will only enact one. For a different explanation of the options and the problems with this trope, see the Star Wars Cleanup thread: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=15787899810A93565000&page=12#comment-2943: Any examples about a characterization within only one work would go only on that work's YMMV page. Any examples pertaining to the character across one or more works would go on AlternativeCharacterInterpretation.Star Wars.
Can The Last Jedi be considered an Idiot Plot? As RLM pointed out pretty much everything in the Poe subplot happens because a refusal to communicate or do simple tasks (like taking an extra minute to part legally). In addition there’s no reason for Finn and Rose to trust DJ or Rey to trust Ben
1-A: Use only AlternativeCharacterInterpretation.Star Wars — collect and relocate all ACI examples there and examples would no longer appear on the various YMMV pages. (Organization of said page by work or by character would be determined through further discussion.)
1-B: Use AlternativeCharacterInterpretation.Star Wars to duplicate all examples in one place and also have the same examples duplicated on the YMMV pages for each work discussed. This would mean each example appears in at least 2 places.
2: Relocate all examples currently on AlternativeCharacterInterpretation.Star Wars to the YMMV pages for each work the example discusses, then cut this page. There would no longer be a page for franchise-wide examples.
