This is discussion archived from a time before the current discussion method was installed.
Rebochan: I haven't played the game, but right now, this page really reads more like a screed against the game by someone who just didn't like it.
Momonga: I've played it, and the page still reads more like a screed against the game. There are a lot of Thomas Covenant mentions, too, considering the two are not actually by the same people or anything. Maybe I'll try to add some neutral and/or positive things.
Chibi-Kibou: I've read The Chronicles Of Thomas Covenant, and frankly, the mentions of it on this page have made me want to play Eternal Sonata all the more o.o So eh, 'not all bad, right?
Dammerung: I very much enjoyed the game and I've tried to round the article out a little. One of my main complaints about the recent-gen RPGs is they aren't traditional enough, and Eternal Sonata fed my appetite. Now somebody bring back the overhead world map and airship!
Momonga: Thank you! It looks much more balanced now. I love this game... I'm currently playing the PS 3 version, and I keep finding new tropes to add, hence my obsessive editing.
GDwarf: I edited down a few more comments that were overly-pejorative. Someone really hated this game, didn't they? Also, I note that the article mentions that the plot is old and cliche, and also mentions that it would be highly original if The Chronicles Of Thomas Covenant didn't exist. Those two seem mutually exclusive.
Wild Knight: I just started playing it myself and am taking it as a bit of a history lesson on the ordeals of a composer I should know more about but don't. Hey, if I can get that from a JRPG, all the better, I love JRPGs...My question is, though: isn't promoting a piece of work on an entirely unrelated work's page considered just the slightest bit rude? Y'know, for the same reason it's considered impolite to add a bullet point to talk about how series X is an example of Y trope when the original example was of series Z? I'm sure The Chronicles Of Thomas Covenant is a fine series, but this isn't its page...
