Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / ThePowerOfHate

Go To

Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
By the end of the series, when he\'s 9 years old she admits she loves him. In the last chapter Rin is shown saying he wants to marry her, by then he\'s around 13 years old. The sequel (Buku wo Tsutsumu Tsuki no Hikari) adds a little more detail, it shows that the relationship got more serious and Alice got pregnant when Rin was 15.

You can argue Rin is mature for his age (since Shion\'s memories made him grow up too soon) but he was a dad at 16 years old while he was still in high-school, he\'s very young compared to her, even Alice herself is aware of that, and she planed to raise their child on her own if needed.
to:
By the end of the series, when he\\\'s 9 years old she admits she loves him. In the last chapter Rin is shown saying he wants to marry her, by then he\\\'s around 13 years old.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
It refers to Alice and Rin relationship.
to:
It refers to Alice and Rin relationship. It\\\'s used more as a theme, as the manga don\\\'t have any explicit scenes.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
You can argue Rin is mature for his age (since Shion\'s memories made him grow up too soon) but he was a dad at 16 years old while he was still in high-school, he\'s very young compared to her.
to:
You can argue Rin is mature for his age (since Shion\\\'s memories made him grow up too soon) but he was a dad at 16 years old while he was still in high-school, he\\\'s very young compared to her, even Alice herself is aware of that, and she planed to raise their child on her own if needed.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
By the end of the series, when he\'s 9 years old she admits she loves him. In the last chapter Rin is shown saying he wants to marry her, by then he\'s around 13 years old. In the sequel (Buku wo Tsutsumu Tsuki no Hikari) shows that the relationship got more serious and Alice got pregnant when Rin was 15.
to:
By the end of the series, when he\\\'s 9 years old she admits she loves him. In the last chapter Rin is shown saying he wants to marry her, by then he\\\'s around 13 years old. The sequel (Buku wo Tsutsumu Tsuki no Hikari) adds a little more detail, it shows that the relationship got more serious and Alice got pregnant when Rin was 15.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
By the end of the series, when he\'s 9 years old she admits she loves him more than Shion. In the last chapter Rin is shown saying he wants to marry her, by then he\'s around 13 years old. In the sequel (Buku wo Tsutsumu Tsuki no Hikari) shows that the relationship got more serious and Alice got pregnant when Rin was 15.
to:
By the end of the series, when he\\\'s 9 years old she admits she loves him. In the last chapter Rin is shown saying he wants to marry her, by then he\\\'s around 13 years old. In the sequel (Buku wo Tsutsumu Tsuki no Hikari) shows that the relationship got more serious and Alice got pregnant when Rin was 15.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
IMO it\'s arguable. It refers to Alice and Rin relationship.
to:
It refers to Alice and Rin relationship.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
Alice is 16 years old and Rin is 7 years old on the beginning of the series. Rin develops feeling for Alice but he\'s not corresponded for several years (Alice even gets freaked out when Rin steals a kiss). The notes on the end of the series say they end up marring and had a child and that is the origin of this question.
to:
They have a 9 years difference, Alice is 16 years old and Rin is 7 years old on the beginning of the series when Rin develops feeling for Alice, and her family agrees to an engagement thought she doesn\\\'t correspond his feelings at first and isn\\\'t pleased with the arrangement.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
I think the author wanted to avoid it being considered shotacon (at least an obvious one, with an 18 x 9 year old on the end of the series), because the sequel (Buku o Tsutsumu Tsuki no Hikari) shows that they didn\'t met for some years after the series ended, and got in the relationship, and Alice got pregnant, when Rin was 15.
to:
By the end of the series, when he\\\'s 9 years old she admits she loves him more than Shion. In the last chapter Rin is shown saying he wants to marry her, by then he\\\'s around 13 years old. In the sequel (Buku wo Tsutsumu Tsuki no Hikari) shows that the relationship got more serious and Alice got pregnant when Rin was 15.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
So if the the cut line for shotacon is around 13 years old or less (arguable, when a child stops being a child?), then he\'d be above it, but it\'s still a 24 year old adult with a 15 year old. Even if he\'s mature for his age, he was a dad while in high-school (the series shows people being aware of the awkwardness of this, mistaking the son for a little brother).
to:
You can argue Rin is mature for his age (since Shion\\\'s memories made him grow up too soon) but he was a dad at 16 years old while he was still in high-school, he\\\'s very young compared to her.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
I think since the author wanted to avoid it being considered shotacon (at least an extreme one, with an 9 year old on the end of the series), because the sequel (Buku o Tsutsumu Tsuki no Hikari) shows that they didn\'t met for some years after the series ended, and got in the relationship, and Alice got pregnant, when Rin was 15.
to:
I think the author wanted to avoid it being considered shotacon (at least an obvious one, with an 18 x 9 year old on the end of the series), because the sequel (Buku o Tsutsumu Tsuki no Hikari) shows that they didn\\\'t met for some years after the series ended, and got in the relationship, and Alice got pregnant, when Rin was 15.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
So if the the cut line for shotacon is around 13 years old or less (arguable, when a child stops being a child?), then he\'d be above it, but it\'s still a 23 year old adult with a 15 year old, even if he\'s mature for his age, he was a dad while in high-school (the series shows people being aware of the awkwardness of this, mistaking the son for a little brother).
to:
So if the the cut line for shotacon is around 13 years old or less (arguable, when a child stops being a child?), then he\\\'d be above it, but it\\\'s still a 24 year old adult with a 15 year old. Even if he\\\'s mature for his age, he was a dad while in high-school (the series shows people being aware of the awkwardness of this, mistaking the son for a little brother).
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
It\'s arguable. It refers to Alice and Rin relationship.
Alice is 16 years old and Rin is 7 years old on the beginning of the series. Rin develops feeling for Alice but he\'s not corresponded for several years (Alice even gets freaked out when Rin steals a kiss). The notes on the end of the series say they end up marring and had a child but, the sequel (Buku o Tsutsumu Tsuki no Hikari) shows that they didn\'t met for some years after the series ended, and got in the relationship, and Alice got pregnant, when Rin was 15. So if the the cut line for shotacon (and this is arguable) is around 13 years old or less, he\'d be above it by then, even being 9 years younger.
to:
IMO it\\\'s arguable. It refers to Alice and Rin relationship.

Alice is 16 years old and Rin is 7 years old on the beginning of the series. Rin develops feeling for Alice but he\\\'s not corresponded for several years (Alice even gets freaked out when Rin steals a kiss). The notes on the end of the series say they end up marring and had a child and that is the origin of this question.

I think since the author wanted to avoid it being considered shotacon (at least an extreme one, with an 9 year old on the end of the series), because the sequel (Buku o Tsutsumu Tsuki no Hikari) shows that they didn\\\'t met for some years after the series ended, and got in the relationship, and Alice got pregnant, when Rin was 15.

So if the the cut line for shotacon is around 13 years old or less (arguable, when a child stops being a child?), then he\\\'d be above it, but it\\\'s still a 23 year old adult with a 15 year old, even if he\\\'s mature for his age, he was a dad while in high-school (the series shows people being aware of the awkwardness of this, mistaking the son for a little brother).
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
Alice is 16 years old and Rin is 7 years old on the beginning of the series. Rin develops feeling for Alice but he\'s not corresponded for several years (Alice even gets freaked out when Rin steals a kiss). The notes on the end of the series say they end up marring and had a child but, the sequel (Buku o Tsutsumu Tsuki no Hikari) shows that they didn\'t met for some years after the series ended, and got in the relationship, and Alice got pregnant, when Rin was 15. So if the the cut line for shotacon (and this is arguable) is around 13 years old or less, he\'d be above by then, even being 9 years younger.
to:
Alice is 16 years old and Rin is 7 years old on the beginning of the series. Rin develops feeling for Alice but he\\\'s not corresponded for several years (Alice even gets freaked out when Rin steals a kiss). The notes on the end of the series say they end up marring and had a child but, the sequel (Buku o Tsutsumu Tsuki no Hikari) shows that they didn\\\'t met for some years after the series ended, and got in the relationship, and Alice got pregnant, when Rin was 15. So if the the cut line for shotacon (and this is arguable) is around 13 years old or less, he\\\'d be above it by then, even being 9 years younger.
Top