Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / FieryRedhead

Go To

Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
Samara is an asari Justicar. I refuse to believe you don\'t know the difference, and aren\'t just playing up her apparent moral ambiguity (even though there is literally no one else on deck where you can find a \'\'book\'\' on her morals) for the sake of making Jacob seem worse. Even if it \'\'was\'\' unfair, being unfair \'\'doesn\'t make him a JerkAss!\'\'
to:
Samara is an asari Justicar. I refuse to believe you don\\\'t know the difference, and aren\\\'t just playing up her apparent moral ambiguity (even though there is literally no one else on deck where you can find a \\\'\\\'book\\\'\\\' on their morals) for the sake of making Jacob seem worse. Even if it \\\'\\\'was\\\'\\\' unfair, being unfair \\\'\\\'doesn\\\'t make him a JerkAss!\\\'\\\'
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
Again. Being suspicious of Thane does not make him a JerkAss. Being a part of Cerberus does not mean he has to give up any sense of logic or any grain of suspicion. It\'s not hypocritical--even if it \'\'were\'\', that \'\'doesn\'t make him a JerkAss\'\'.Everyone works for Cerberus. You could be the most pure of Paragons, the antithesis of all Jerk Asses everywhere, and \'\'you work for Cerberus\'\'. Kelly works for Cerberus. Kenneth and Gabby work for Cerberus. They are not Jerk Asses.
to:
Again. Being suspicious of Thane does not make him a JerkAss. Being a part of Cerberus does not mean he has to give up any sense of logic or any grain of suspicion. It\\\'s not hypocritical--even if it \\\'\\\'were\\\'\\\', that \\\'\\\'doesn\\\'t make him a JerkAss\\\'\\\'.Everyone works for Cerberus. You could be the most pure of Paragons, the antithesis of all Jerk Asses everywhere, and \\\'\\\'you\\\'\\\' work for Cerberus. Kelly works for Cerberus. Kenneth and Gabby work for Cerberus. They are not Jerk Asses.
Changed line(s) 4 from:
n
2) Geth, up until that point, are presumed to share one sentience. Since you could have been attacked by geth in your directly preceding mission, if you so wish, there is \'\'no reason\'\' to believe \'\'this\'\' geth is different--you don\'t even know that\'s possible. Really. Stop and think about that. That is the most important part of this argument--that racial profiling doesn\'t really exist for them until the schism becomes apparent. We might call them a race, but they operate as one individual. This is more like judging a particular person based on past criminal record.
to:
2) Geth, up until that point, are presumed to share one sentience. Since you could have been attacked by geth in your directly preceding mission, if you so wish, there is \\\'\\\'no reason\\\'\\\' to believe \\\'\\\'this\\\'\\\' geth is different--you don\\\'t even know that\\\'s possible. Really. Stop and think about that. That is the most important part of this argument--that racial profiling doesn\\\'t really exist for them until the schism becomes apparent. We might call them a race, but they operate as one individual. This is more like judging a particular person based on past criminal record.\\\\\\\\
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Tali pulls a gun on Legion even when she knows he\'s different, that the schism exists. You need to prove that Jacob was being unreasonable by wanting a war enemy dead before brushing off that argument. As I\'ve pointed out:
to:
Tali pulls a gun on Legion even when she knows he\\\'s different, that the schism exists. You need to prove that Jacob was being unreasonable by wanting a war enemy dead before brushing off that argument. As I\\\'ve pointed out:\\\\\\\\
\\\\\\\\
1) Geth are expert hackers. Miranda, Queen of Terrible Decisions, placed him in the AI Core of your ship.\\\\\\\\
2) Geth, up until that point, are presumed to share one sentience. Since you could have been attacked by geth in your directly preceding mission, if you so wish, there is \\\'\\\'no reason\\\'\\\' to believe \\\'\\\'this\\\'\\\' geth is different--you don\\\'t even know that\\\'s possible. Really. Stop and think about that. That is the most important part of this argument--that racial profiling doesn\\\'t really exist for them until the schism becomes apparent. We might call them a race, but they operate as one individual. This is more like judging a particular person based on past criminal record.
3) He does not show any hostility towards Legion after. He never talks about Legion. But, as far as we know, he rests or puts aside his fears.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
1) Geth are expert hackers. Miranda, Queen of Terrible Decisions, placed him in the AI Core of your ship.
2) Geth, up until that point, are presumed to share one sentience. Since you could have been attacked by geth in your directly preceding mission, if you so wish, there is \'\'no reason\'\' to believe \'\'this\'\' geth is different--you don\'t even know that\'s possible. Really. Stop and think about that. That is the most important part of this argument--that racial profiling doesn\'t really exist for them until the schism becomes apparent. We might call them a race, but they operate as one individual. This is more like judging a particular person based on past criminal record.
3) He does not show any hostility towards Legion after. He never talks about Legion. But, as far as we know, he rests or puts aside his fears.
to:
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
Again. Being suspicious of Thane does not make him a JerkAss. Being a part of Cerberus does not mean he has to give up any sense of logic or any grain of suspicion. It\'s not hypocritical--even if it \'\'were\'\', that \'\'doesn\'t make him a JerkAss\'\'.Everyone works for Cerberus. You could be the most pure of Paragons, the antithesis of all JerkAsses everywhere, and \'\'you work for Cerberus\'\'. Kelly works for Cerberus. Kenneth and Gabby work for Cerberus. They are not JerkAsses.
to:
Again. Being suspicious of Thane does not make him a JerkAss. Being a part of Cerberus does not mean he has to give up any sense of logic or any grain of suspicion. It\\\'s not hypocritical--even if it \\\'\\\'were\\\'\\\', that \\\'\\\'doesn\\\'t make him a JerkAss\\\'\\\'.Everyone works for Cerberus. You could be the most pure of Paragons, the antithesis of all Jerk Asses everywhere, and \\\'\\\'you work for Cerberus\\\'\\\'. Kelly works for Cerberus. Kenneth and Gabby work for Cerberus. They are not Jerk Asses.
Changed line(s) 11 from:
n
You cannot construe \'\'one\'\' instance of \'\'possible\'\' JerkAssery into making a character into a JerkAss. That is ignoring the essence of the trope itself to suit your agenda.
to:
You cannot construe \\\'\\\'one\\\'\\\' instance of \\\'\\\'possible\\\'\\\' Jerk Assery into making a character into a JerkAss. That is ignoring the essence of the trope itself to suit your agenda.
Top